Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

244 La. 199

151 So.2d 371

State v. Robinson

Supreme Court of Louisiana

Decided March 25, 1963

Supreme Court of Louisiana · decided 1963-03-25

Cited by 11 later decisions — most recently May 1969

11 state decisions

Relies on State v. Honeycutt · State v. Picou · State v. Roy

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1963-03-25

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

SANDERS, Justice.

¶1This criminal proceeding is now before us on the state’s motion to dismiss the appeal.1 The basis for the motion is that the hills of exception were neither submitted to the trial judge nor signed before the appeal was perfected.

¶2In 1950, the Grand Jury of Rapides Parish indicted the defendant for murder. The defendant interposed a plea of insanity. The Lunacy Commission, appointed by the court, reported that he was “presently insane.” Subsequently, the court committed the defendant to the East Louisiana State Hospital.

¶3On May 22, 1962, the staff of the East Louisiana State Hospital reported to the ■court that the defendant was “presently ■sane.” The court then appointed two psychiatrists to re-examine the defendant. Upon re-examination, they reported that the defendant was suffering from a mental disorder which rendered him unable to assist in his defense. Thereafter, the court ruled that the defendant was “presently insane” and ordered him to be returned to the hospital.

¶4Through counsel, the defendant filed various motions, which were overruled by the ■court. Bills of exception were reserved.

¶5On motion of defense counsel, the court ■granted an order of appeal on July 31, 1962. Defense counsel presented the bills of exception to the trial judge for signature on November 6, 1962. The judge declined to ■sign them.

¶6The failure of the appellant to present the bills of exception to the trial judge for signature prior to the appeal leaves such bills incomplete and legally ineffective. The appeal divested the trial judge of jurisdiction to perfect the bills thereafter. Since the bills were not perfected, they present nothing for appellate review. LSA-R.S. 15:545; State v. Perez, 228 La. 796, 84 So.2d 195; State v. Honeycutt, 218 La. 362, 49 So.2d 610; State v. Roy, 217 La. 1074, 47 So.2d 915; 12 Louisiana Law Review pp. 181-182.

¶7Despite the absence of perfected bills of exception, however, this Court must review the case for errors patent on the face of the record. Hence, the motion to dismiss the appeal is without merit. State v. Picou, 236 La. 421, 107 So.2d 691; State v. Allen, 167 La. 798, 120 So. 372; State v. Casey, 140 La. 143, 72 So. 904.

¶8For the reasons assigned, the motion to dismiss the appeal is overruled.

¶9. The motion was assigned preliminarily and submitted on briefs in accordance with Rule YU, Section 1, Rules of the Supreme Court of Louisiana, 8 LSA-R.S.

/244/la/199 · .json · Public domain