<p>This was a complaint preferred by Prentiss Williams, a grand-juror of the town of Montville, to a justice of the peace, against Samuel Mosier, for selling and keeping spirituous liquor contrary to the statute. The complaint contained two counts; the first charging the defendant with having on the 28th day of August, 1855, sold spirituous and intoxicating liquor; and the second, with keeping such liquor with intent to sell the same.</p> <p>The defendant appeared at the justice’s court, and demurred to the complaint. The justice overruled the demurrer, and found the defendant guilty on both counts, and sentenced him to pay the fines imposed by the statute for each offence. From this judgment he appealed to the superior court, held in November, 1855, at which term the complaint was tried upon the plea of not guilty.</p> <p>In support of the second count of said complaint, the prosecutor introduced as witnesses, one Richards and his wfife, who testified substantially, “ that Mosier had called on said Richards, and said that he was going to New York to purchase liquor for himself and other parties, and intended to go backwards and forwards and accommodate the neighborhood, and wished to know if they desired him to procure any for them; and that Richards asked him to buy two gallons of liquor for him. That subsequently, on the return of Mosier,. Richards sent to him and received two quarts of liquor, which he understood Mosier had bought for him ; and afterwards the accused asked him to pay for what he had taken, and further inquired when he intended to call for the remainder.”</p> <p>The defendant claimed that the evidence did not prove a sale of spirituous liquor, or a keeping with intent to sell, but an agency merely; that it; did not appear that Mosier had any liquor except the two gallons purchased for Richards, and that that was purchased bona fide by Mosier for Richards in New York. He thereupon requested the court to instruct the jury in conformity with this claim.</p> <p>The judge did not comply with this request, but charged the jury substantially as follows: “At the time when the offence charged is alleged to have been committed, contracts for the sale and purchase of spirituous liquor were lawful in the state of New York, and any person might go there and purchase such liquor, if he chose. And when so purchased, if not intended to be sold, the purchaser might bring it into this state and keep it, without violating the statute. And what a person might do himself, he might do by another as his agent. If therefore, Mosier did purchase, bona fide, as the agent of Richards, two gallons of spirituous liquor, whether the money was advanced by Richards or not, and having so purchased it, had it his possession in this state, as agent only, there could be no keeping with intent to sell, and the prisoner should be acquitted. But while this is so, the agency must be one in fact, and not in form only; a real agency, and not a cover to evade the statute. It is for the jury to find whether there was any agency at all, and if there was, whether it was a real or pretended one. No reason is assigned why, if there was an agency for the purchase of two gallons of liquor, it was not delivered by Mosier, or called for by Richards; nor does it appear that that specific quantity was purchased by itself, or that it was otherwise purchased than as part of a cask-full, which was never measured out or set apart for Richards.</p> <p>I think that in this case, where the state, in connection with the other circumstances shown, proved the delivery of spirituous liquor by Mosier to Richards and the demand of payment therefor, and an acknowledgment that he had a further quantity, which he was keeping for him, the burden of proof was thrown upon Mosier, to show that he acted in all this as the agent of Richards, and that the agency, if there was one, was one in fact, and bona fide, and not of form merely, under cover of which the statute might be evaded.”</p> <p>The jury rendered a verdict of guilty on the second count, and the defendant moved for a new trial, on the ground that the charge was erroneous, and also that the verdict was against evidence.</p>