Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

25 Conn. 565

Magie v. Stoddard

Supreme Court of Connecticut

Decided February 15, 1857

Supreme Court of Connecticut · decided 1857-02-15

This was an action of book debt originally brought before a justice of the peace for the county of New Haven. The writ was served by one Charles R. Wheadon as con» stable of the town of New Haven.

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1857-02-15

How this case has been cited

Cited by 10 later decisions — most recently November 1964

10 state decisions

20185718601870188018901900191019201930194019501960decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Hinman, J.

¶1The defendant in this case pleads in abatement, that the officer who undertook to serve the writ as a constable of New Haven, had, a few months previous to his election as such constable, been duly elected and qualified as a justice of the peace, and on this ground it is claimed that he could not by law hold the office of constable, and therefore his attempted service of the writ is no service, and the same should abate and be dismissed. The replication sets up the attempts of the officer to resign hi§ office of justice of the peace, in various ways, before he was qualified as a constable. But it is hardly necessary to discuss the question whether he really succeeded in divesting himself of his judicial functions, in any of the modes in which he attempted to do so; or whether he had a constitutional right to hold the office of constable, even if he was unsuccessful in attempting to resign; because, assuming that the statute which provides that no judge or justice of the peace, shall hold the office of sheriff or constable, is a valid act under the constitution, or that the two offices are so incompatible that the same person can not at the same time hold both of them, which amounts *568to about the same thing, we still think that the acceptance of the office of constable would of itself be a surrender of the office of justice of the peace.

¶2In the case of Milward v. Thatcher, 2 T. R,., 81, it was held that accepting the office of town clerk vacated the office of jurat of the corporation of Hastings, although the office of clerk was inferior to that of jurat, the jurats sitting as judges in a court of record.

¶3This decision, which appears to us to be founded upon correct principles, is sufficient to dispose of the case. We omit therefore to discuss the question whether the service would not be good on the ground that the officer was a constable de facto, whose acts are good as between third persons, although he might himself be disqualified from holding the office. We advise the superior court to render judgment for the plaintiff.

¶4In this opinion the other judges, Storrs and Ellsworth, concurred.

¶5Judgment for plaintiff' advised.

/25/conn/565 · .json · Public domain