Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

25 Okla. 135

105 P 1012

Alcorn v. Dennis

Supreme Court of Oklahoma

Decided November 9, 1909

Supreme Court of Oklahoma · decided 1909-11-09

<p> Error from District Court, Nolle County; Bayard T. Hainer, Judge. </p> <p>. Action by Charles E. Dennis against May. Alcorn and others. Judgment for plaintiff, and defendants bring error.</p> <p>Citing: Cague v. Bank, 86 Ill. 371; McGeagh v. Nordberg, 53 Minn. 234; 12 Enc. PI. & Pr. 271; 24 Cyc. 172; Ileiuiti v. Week, 51 Wis. 368; Han-cheti v. Ives, 49 N. E. 207; Hopkins v. Landfond, 2 N. W. 39; Fano ell v. Murray (Cal.) 38 Pac. 199; Chessman v. Hale, 79 Pac. 255; Biggs v. Lloyd, 11 Pac. 831; Hart v. Cascade Timber Co. (Wash.) 81 Pac. 738; Alworth v. Railway Co. (R. I.) 60 Atl. 884; Corley v. McElmell (N. Y.) 43 N. E. 628.</p> <p>Citing: Hand v. Kennedy, 83 N. Y. 149; Landhan v. Heaver (Md.) 20 L. R. A. 759; 24 Cyc. 171; Thompson v. King. 173 Mass. 439; 12 Enc. Pi. ■& Pr. 272; Haley v. Bank (Nev.) 12 L. R. A. 819; Hutchinson v. Ward, 99 N. Y. 708; State v. Packenham (Wash.) 82 Pac. 597; Town v. Leake (S. C.) 50 S. E. 541; West v. Bank (Mo.) 85 S. W. 601; Zilke v. Woodley (Wash.) 78 Pac. 299.</p>

Key passage — most relied on by later courts

““To permit amendments when not changing the cause of action rests within the sound- discretion of the trial court, and will not be disturbed on appeal unless it affirmatively appears that its exercise has been abused to the prejudice of the complaining party.” (Citing many authorities.)”

quoted by 1 later decision, including Cimarron Valley Pipe Line Co. v. Holmes

Relies on McCann v. McCann · Hartford Fire Insurance v. Redding · Ferrea v. Chabot

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Affirmed · Decided 1909-11-09

How this case has been cited

Cited by 43 later decisions — most recently October 1943 · most notably Kingfisher Mill & Elev. Co. v. Westbrook (1920), Chas. T. Derr Construction Co. v. Gelruth (1911)

43 state decisions

29019091910192019301940decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

WILLIAMS, J.

¶1 1.. The defendant in error, as plaintiff, declared in two counts. The first was on a promissory note wherein it was alleged that the interest was to be paid semiannually. The purported copy of such note attached to the petition as an exhibit did not contain such clause, and after the trial had been begun, and objection was made by the plaintiffs in error (defendants below) to the introduction of the original note on account of a 'variance, the plaintiff (defendant in error here) was permitted to amend.

¶2 To permit amendments when not changing the cause of action *137 rests within the sound discretion of the trial court and will not be disturbed on appeal unless it affirmatively appears that its. exercise has been abused to the prejudice of the complaining party. Swope v. Burnham, 6 Okla. 736, 52 Pac. 924; Tecumseh State Bank v. Maddox, 4 Okla. 583, 46 Pac. 563; Armour Packing Co. v. Orrick, 4 Okla. 661, 46 Pac. 573; Church v. A., T. & S. F. R. Co., 1 Okla. 44, 29 Pac. 530; El Reno Electric Light & Telephone Co. v. Jennison, 5 Okla. 759, 50 Pac. 144; Lookabaugh v. La Vance, 6 Okla. 358, 49 Pac. 65; Limerick v. Lee, 17 Okla. 165, 87 Pac. 859; Piper v. Choctaw Northern Townsite & Improvement Co., 16 Okla. 436, 85 Pac. 965; Lookabaugh v. Bowmaker, 21 Okla. 489, 96 Pac. 651; Mulhall v. Mulhall, 3 Okla. 304, 41 Pac. 109; section 4343 (c. 66, art. 8, § 145) Wilson’s Rev. & Ann. St. 1903; Rogers v. Hodgson, 46 Kan. 276, 26 Pac. 732; Teberg v. Swenson, 32 Kan. 224, 4 Pac. 83.

¶3 2. The plaintiffs in error not having asked permission to withdraw their waiver as to trial by jury, but having proceeded under the original waiver after the amendment had been permitted, will not be heard to complain for the first time in their motion for new tral that they were thereby deprived of the right of trial by jury. However, there are authorities that hold that, when a jury has been waived as to the trial of a cause, such waiver applies to all issues not only then existing, but also to those raised by subsequent pleadings. Thompson v. King, 173 Mass. 439, 53 N. E. 910; Dennie v. Williams, 135 Mass. 28; Lanahan v. Heaver, 77 Md. 605; 26 Atl. 866, 20 L. R. A. 756; Tracy v. Falvey, 102 App. Div. 585, 92 N. Y. Supp 625; Collins v. Young, 118 N. C. 265, 23 S. E. 1005; Keystone Driller Co. v. Worth, 117 N. C. 515, 23 S. E. 427; Perry v. Tupper, 77 N. C. 413; Hauser v. Metzger, 1 Cin. R. (Ohio) 164; Ferrea v. Chabot, 121 Cal. 233, 53 Pac. 689, 1092; Hartford Ins. Co. v. Redding, 47 Fla. 228, 37 South. 62, 67 L. R. A. 518, 110 Am. St. Rep. 118; Wittenberg v. Onsgard, 78 Minn. 342, 81 N. W. 14, 47 L. R. A. 141.

¶4 3. All the evidence in this case was parol. As to whether or not the note was altered after it was executed, there was a conflict. The general and special finding of the trial court against *138 the plaintiffs in error on that question is therefore conclusive here. McCann v. McCann, 24 Okla. 264, 103 Pac. 694; Seward v. Casler et al., 24 Okla. 275, 103 Pac. 740.

¶5 The judgment of the lower court is affirmed. •

All the Justices concur.
/25/okla/135 · .json · Public domain