Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

25 Utah 2d 93

Thompson v. Brewster

Utah Supreme Court

Decided October 23, 1970

Utah Supreme Court · decided 1970-10-23

Cited by 2 later decisions — most recently April 1982

Relies on Christy Et Ux. v. Guild Et Ux.

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1970-10-23

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

HENRIOD, Justice:

¶1Appeal from a quiet title judgment. Affirmed, with no costs awarded.

¶2Plaintiffs sold their inchoate interest in a motel to Brewster under a written uniform real estate contract. A five-day notice of default was served upon him, requiring payment of delinquencies or vacate the premises, which was ignored. Thereafter notice of termination for breach was served, which also was ignored. Plaintiffs took peaceable possession, and Brewster made no effort to reclaim the property during the next ensuing four months, when he filed for bankruptcy.

¶3Brewster had made purported payments by checks, many of which bounced like popcorn at a carnival, causing breaches to eventuate almost monthly and with regularity. The record fails to reflect that defendant was in any sense lulled into a false sense of security justifying any reliance on a continuation of repeated defaults, and we believe and hold that Christy v. Guild, 101 Utah 313, 121 P.2d 401 (1942), relied on by appellant, is not controlling under the facts of the instant case.

¶4The Referee in Bankruptcy correctly held that the transaction was secured and not subject to processing in the bankruptcy court, and hence not such as to justify any stay of execution in the state court.

¶5Defendant says the trial court erred in not staying the litigation, which is an urgence without merit. He also urges error in allowing a forfeiture of the contract,— which the defendant, not the plaintiffs, broke, The record shows no unconscionability that would impel a Chancellor to prevent an inequitable forfeiture. It is further urged that Brewster, of all people, should have been awarded damages, presumably to immunize him, a defaulter, from the immortal maxim that “Equity will not pick up pins.” We cannot subscribe to such contention.

CROCKETT, C. J., and CALLISTER, TUCKETT and ELLETT, TJ. concur.
/25/utah2d/93 · .json · Public domain