Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

25 Vt. 570

Morgan v. Houston

Supreme Court of Vermont

Decided May 15, 1853

Supreme Court of Vermont · decided 1853-05-15

Petition -for a new-trial, on the ground of surprise, in the ruling of the (Court, and newly discovered evidence. The County .Court, — Poland, J. presiding, — dismissed the petition. To which decision fthe plaintiffs excepted. fl. Surprise has ever been considered-a good c-ause, for the granting The particular consideration in this case is, whether the matter of surprise is -of that extent and character, that will authorize the court to interpose ?

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1853-05-15

How this case has been cited

Cited by 9 later decisions — most recently January 1933

9 state decisions

50185318601870188018901900191019201930decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1The opinion of the court was delivered by

Redfield, Ch. J.

¶2This is a petition for a new trial, on the-ground of surprise, at the trial, and newly discovered evidence.

¶31. One ground of surprise, on the part of the petitioners, is that the County Court ruled the law different from what they expected,, and that ruling was affirmed, in this court. This could never form the basis of a petition for a new trial. This is a surprise that overtakes every body concerned in the administration of civil justice, every day of his life. Human opinion is infinitely various, and always will be.

¶4If a party supposes it possible, that evidence exists, which will *572enable liim to avoid the effect of a decision, against him, he should obtain a delay and search for the evidence. But if instead of doing that, he ventures to rely upon his exceptions, and fail there, or if he move for continuance, which the court refuse, it could not fail to be of evil example to grant relief, by petition for new trial. In one case, it would encourage rash experiment, and in the other, would be virtually granting a new trial, because the court unreasonably refused a delay of the trial. This seems to cover all, which is alleged, as surprise.

¶52. The newly discovered evidence being the record of the allowance of the committee’s account, was all of record, in this court, and might have been found, upon reasonable search, in the proper place, and at the proper time, which seems not to have been done. To grant a new trial, on that account, would be to relieve the party, from the consequences of his own neglect.

¶6There does not seem to be any just ground, for granting this petition, and it is dismissed with costs.

/25/vt/570 · .json · Public domain