Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

251 Wis. 619

30 N.W.2d 617

Smith v. Vogt

Wisconsin Supreme Court

Decided November 18, 1947

Wisconsin Supreme Court · decided 1947-11-18

Cited by 3 later decisions — most recently December 1983

3 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1947-11-18

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1 The following memorandum was filed February 19, 1948:

RosenbeRRY, C. J.

¶2 (on motion for rehearing). In support of their motion for rehearing the defendants argue that the court overlooked a well-established principle of law and failed to apply the provisions of sec. 251.09, Stats., and reverse the judgment appealed from on the ground that the real controversy had not yet been fully tried.

¶3 This argument fails to take into consideration that the rule requiring a counterclaim in ejectment cases, where affirma *624 tive relief is asked for, is statutory, and applies specially in these cases. To reverse the cause would merely give the defendants an opportunity to try their case twice on the same ■ grounds. We have examined the record and find no grounds upon which the judgment can be reversed in the interests of justice. In spite of the defective pleading the case seems to have been fully tried.

¶4 By the Court. — Motion denied with $25 costs.-

/251/wis/619 · .json · Public domain