Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

257 Pa. Super. 30

Commonwealth v. Fortune

Superior Court of Pennsylvania

Decided July 12, 1978

Superior Court of Pennsylvania · decided 1978-07-12

Cited by 4 later decisions — most recently July 1981

4 state decisions

Key passage — most relied on by later courts

“Appellant waived his right to a jury trial. However, the waiver colloquy did not meet the requirements of Commonwealth v. Williams, 454 Pa. 368 , 312 A.2d 597 (1973), in that the lower court failed to inform appellant that the jury would be composed of his peers, chosen from the members of his community.”

quoted by 1 later decision, including 289 Pa. Super. 278 - Commonwealth v. Fortune

“who may (if appellant wishes it) raise the jury-waiver and ineffectiveness issues in a new brief filed at this term number.”

quoted by 1 later decision, including 289 Pa. Super. 278 - Commonwealth v. Fortune

Relies on Commonwealth v. Williams · Commonwealth v. Fox · 252 Pa. Super. 103 - Commonwealth v. Liska

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1978-07-12

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

SPAETH, Judge:

¶1Appellate counsel asks leave to withdraw, arguing that she can find no issues on which appellant might reasonably expect to get appellate relief.

¶2In such cases, we are required to make our own “review of the record and brief,” Commonwealth v. Liska, 252 Pa.Super. 103, 108, 380 A.2d 1303, 1305 (1977). Doing so here, we find that appellate counsel is mistaken.

¶3Appellant waived his right to a jury trial. However, the waiver colloquy did not meet the requirements of Commonwealth v. Williams, 454 Pa. 368, 312 A.2d 597 (1973), in that the lower court failed to inform appellant that the jury would be composed of his peers, chosen from the members of his community. Id.,454 Pa. at 373, 312 A.2d at 600.

¶4To raise this issue on appeal, appellant would have to argue that trial counsel was ineffective in failing to raise the issue in post-verdict motions. Commonwealth v. Murray, 233 Pa.Super. 10, 13-14, 334 A.2d 678, 680 (1975). Here, trial counsel was a member of the Defender’s Association, as is appellate counsel. Although appellate counsel is not precluded from raising a colleague’s ineffectiveness, Commonwealth v. Fox, 476 Pa. 475, 383 A.2d 199 (1978) (dictum), appellate counsel here has made it plain that she is unwilling to do so, as she feels “burdened with an obvious conflict of interest.” Appellant’s Brief at 11 n.*.

¶5Under these circumstances, we remand the case for appointment of new, non-Defender counsel who may (if appellant wishes it) raise the jury-waiver and ineffectiveness issues in a new brief filed at this term number. So ordered.

JACOBS, President Judge and VAN der VOORT, J., dissent.WATKINS, former President Judge, did not participate in the consideration or decision of this case.
/257/pasuper/30 · .json · Public domain