Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

258 F.2d 165

Docket No. 14446.

Turner v. United States

District of Columbia Circuit Court of Appeals

Argued June 23, 1958.

Decided July 10, 1958.

District of Columbia Circuit Court of Appeals · decided 1958-07-10

Cited by 58 later decisions — most recently May 1965 · most notably Plummer v. United States (1958), Smith v. United States (1959)

46 federal appellate · 8 district ·

2 counsel of record

Key passage — most relied on by later courts

““The appeal now before us is from the denial without hearing of a motion under Section 2255, Title 28, United States Code, filed February 8, 1957. It was the third such motion of the same import filed by Morris. No appeal was taken from the denials of the first two motions. The statute (Section 2255 of Title 28) provides that ‘The sentencing court shall not be required to entertain a second or successive motion for similar relief on behalf of the same prisoner.’ Thus under the specific terms of the statute the court was not required to entertain the motion now before us. That disposes of the case.””

quoted by 1 later decision, including Smith v. United States

““Absent some allegation or evidence as to what is the ‘justifiable reason’ or ‘unawareness,’ the District Court is under no duty to grant a hearing on what appear on the face of the petition to be old claims; indeed without such allegations the District Judge cannot even be aware of a possible basis for exercising his discretion to grant a hearing, applying the standards of Price v. Johnston * *”

quoted by 1 later decision, including Smith v. United States

Applies 28 U.S.C. § 2255 (Antiterrorism and Effective Death Penalty Act of 1996)

Relies on Price v. Johnston · Salinger v. Loisel · Wong Doo v. United States

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Opinion by (per_curiam) · Decided 1958-07-10

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1*166Mr. T. Emmett McKenzie, Washington, D. C., for appellant. Appellant filed a brief pro se.

¶2Mr. Edgar T. Bellinger, Asst. U. S. Atty., with whom Messrs. Oliver Gasch, U. S. Atty., and Carl W. Belcher, Asst. U. S. Atty., were on the brief, for ap-pellee.

¶3Before Madden, Judge, United States Court of Claims,* and Bazelon and Burger, Circuit Judges.

¶5PER CURIAM.

¶6Appellant was convicted in 1958 for violation of narcotic laws. On direct appeal we affirmed.1 About three years later, appellant filed a motion under 28 U.S.C. § 2255 to vacate his sentence, alleging denial of a fair trial by misconduct of a juror — described now by his counsel as the juror’s failure to live up to a promise to be “sympathetic” to appellant. The District Court denied his motion and on appeal from that denial we dismissed.2

¶7In December 1957, appellant again filed a motion under section 2255, alleging a number of violations of constitutional rights; some new, and some previously raised on the direct appeal. The District Court denied relief without a hearing, on the ground that the motion was a second or successive motion,3 and alternatively, that the files and records conclusively showed that appellant was entitled to no relief.

¶8 Where there has been a previous appeal or a previous 2255 motion, the District Judge has discretion to deny relief as to those allegations which could have been, but were not, raised in the earlier proceeding, unless the petitioner has “some justifiable reason he was previously unable to assert his rights,” or *167unless he was “unaware of the significance of relevant facts.”4 Absent some allegation or evidence as to what is the “justifiable reason” or “unawareness,” the District Court is under no duty to grant a hearing on what appear on the face of the petition to be old claims; indeed without such allegations the District Judge cannot even be aware of a possible basis for exercising his discretion to grant a hearing, applying the standards of Price v. Johnston, supra note 4. Here those of appellant’s allegations reviewable on a § 2255 motion could readily have been raised on the first § 2255 motion, and of course all of the allegations could have been raised on the direct appeal. No indication of any “justifiable reason” or “unawareness” is apparent or alleged.5 Hence, the District Court did not abuse its discretion in refusing relief6 on the grounds this was a second or successive motion for similar relief.

¶9Affirmed.

¶10BAZELON, Circuit Judge, concurs in the result.

/258/f2d/165 · .json · Public domain