Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

264 Conn. 538

St. George v. Gordon

Supreme Court of Connecticut

Decided July 1, 2003

Supreme Court of Connecticut · decided 2003-07-01

Cited by 61 later decisions — most recently July 2017 · most notably State v. Skakel (2006), Conboy v. State (2009)

2 district · 59 state decisions

Relies on State v. Courchesne · Martinez v. Department of Public Safety · Mandell v. Gavin

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 2003-07-01

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

SULLIVAN, C. J.,

¶1concurring. I agree with the majority’s conclusion in this matter except on the issue of statutory interpretation. My position on this issue continues to be the same as set forth in my concurrence in Mandell v. Gavin, 262 Conn. 659, 672, 816 A.2d 619 (2003), and in the dissenting opinion by Justice Zarella, in which I joined, in State v. Courchesne, 262 Conn. 537, 597, 816 A.2d 562 (2003).

BORDEN, J., with whom NORCOTT, J.,

¶2joins, concurring. I agree with and join the majority opinion. I write separately, however, to register my substantive agreement with the reasoning of part II of Justice Katz’s dissenting opinion, although I do not join in its result.

¶3In part II of her dissenting opinion, Justice Katz cogently analyzes why Martinez v. Dept. of Public Safety, 263 Conn. 74, 818 A.2d 758 (2003), in which I joined Justice Norcott’s dissent, was wrongly decided. I agree with Justice Katz in that regard, for all of the reasons stated in Justice Norcott’s dissent therein; see id., 88-93; as well as all of the reasons stated by Justice Katz in the present case. Nonetheless, I decline to vote to overrule Martinezbecause it was an en banc decision that was very recently issued by this court. Under these circumstances, a due respect for stare decisis, especially in the area of statutory interpretation, counsels against such prompt judicial action.

/264/conn/538 · .json · Public domain