Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

264 F.2d 476

Docket No. 17424.

Judy v. Judy

Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals

Decided March 20, 1959.

Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals · decided 1959-03-20

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently March 1959

1 federal appellate ·

2 counsel of record

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Opinion by (per_curiam) · Decided 1959-03-20

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1Louis Vernell, Vernell & Tulin, Miami Beach, Fla., Lionel L. Tulin, Miami Beach, Fla., of counsel, for appellant.

¶2James A. Dixon, Miami, Fla., William B. Martin, Lexington, Ky., Dixon, DeJarnette, Bradford & Williams, Miami, Fla., Yancey, Martin & Ockerman, Lexington, Ky., for appellee.

¶3Before RIVES and TUTTLE, Circuit Judges, and SIMPSON, District Judge.

¶4PER CURIAM.

¶5Appellant and appellee had been married for more than 30 years and had reared four boys, when in 1951 appellee secured a divorce in Kentucky and a lump sum alimony judgment for $4,400.00. Appellee sued appellant in Florida on that judgment alleging that he had fraudulently assigned his interest as beneficiary of his aunt’s will to his mother and seeking to set aside that assignment. Appellant defended and counterclaimed, seeking to enforce his claimed rights as beneficial owner in certain valuable property in Kentucky, the title to which was in appellee’s name. The district court awarded appellee judgment for the $4,400.00 and interest thereon but denied appellee relief as to setting aside appellant’s assignment of his interest in his aunt’s estate to his mother. The Court further held that appellant had failed to sustain the burden of proof necessary to establish beneficial ownership in the Kentucky property. This appeal concerns appellant’s claim of beneficial ownership in the Kentucky property.

¶6There was ample evidence to support a finding that appellant had never had enough money to buy the property; that appellee’s father had given her this property in her own right; that previously he had given her two other farms; and that appellant’s own admission to third parties showed that he did not consider the property to be his during the time when he was allegedly managing it.

¶7In order for appellant to prevail as against appellee’s legal title, he had at the very least to show that he had supplied the money with which the property was purchased. The finding of the district court that he had not borne that burden is not clearly erroneous. Rule 52 (a), Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, 28 U.S.C.A.

¶8The judgment is therefore

¶9Affirmed.

/264/f2d/476 · .json · Public domain