Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

266 Mass. 195

Commonwealth v. Godis

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court

Decided February 6, 1929

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · decided 1929-02-06

Relies on Commonwealth v. Russ · Commonwealth v. Cooper · Commonwealth v. Richmond

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1929-02-06

How this case has been cited

Cited by 4 later decisions — most recently November 1966

4 state decisions

2019291930194019501960decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Rugg, C.J,

¶1This complaint charged the defendant with manufacturing intoxicating liquors. St. 1923, c. 370. G. L. c. 138, § 86. She did not testify in her own behalf. Her husband was called as a witness. During cross-examination of him, an assistant district attorney, ■ holding two court records in his hand, after having asked without objection whether the husband had seen the defendant make, or been told by her that she had made, any liquor and having received negative answers, asked the further question: “ . . . knowing that she once pleaded guilty two years ago to the manufacture of liquor, does that refresh your memory at all?” The defendant thereupon asked that a mistrial be declared. The question on suggestion by the judge was withdrawn. The defendant renewed her request that a mistrial be declared. This was denied, the judge saying, ‘ ‘ There is no answer to the question, and there is no evidence of the fact that was embraced in it. The jury will disregard the whole thing.” .

¶2In all this there was no error of law. The action of the judge was prompt, decisive and adequate in pointing out to the jury that there was no evidence before them touching the matter and that they should pay no heed to any part of the incident. It must be presumed that the jury followed this instruction. Whatever may be thought of the question put, the rights of the defendant to a fair trial were fully protected by the presiding judge. It is not necessary to elaborate the point further. In principle the case is governed by numerous decisions. Commonwealth v. Richmond, 207 Mass. 240, 248, 249, 250. Commonwealth v. Russ, 232 Mass. 58, 81. Commonwealth v. Festo, 251 Mass. 275, 281, 282. Common*197wealth v. McIntosh, 259 Mass. 388, 390. Commonwealth v. Jacobson, 260 Mass. 311,328, 329. Commonwealth v. Cooper, 264 Mass. 368, 374. There is nothing at variance with this conclusion in State v. Rhys, 40 Mont. 131, upon which the defendant relied in oral argument. There was no want of judicial discretion in refusing to declare a mistrial. Claffey v. Fenelon, 263 Mass. 427.

¶3The appeal of the defendant from the denial of a motion for a new trial based upon the same incident presents no question of law. The disposition of that motion rested in sound judicial discretion. Commonwealth v. Borasky, 214 Mass. 313, 322.

¶4Appeal dismissed.

¶5Exceptions overruled.

/266/mass/195 · .json · Public domain