Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

27 Ga. 494

Fleming v. Collins

Supreme Court of Georgia

Decided March 15, 1859

Supreme Court of Georgia · decided 1859-03-15

In Equity, from Gilmer county. Decision by Judge Rice, October Term, 1858. This was a bill filed by William H. Collins, against Porter Fleming, administrator of John A. Meigs, deceased, to enjoin Fleming from prosecuting an action of ejectment against complainant, for lot of land No. 175, in the seventh district, and second section of Gilmer county.

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently September 1930

1 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1859-03-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1By the Court.

Lumpkin J.

¶2delivering the opinion.

¶3Ought the injunction in this case to have been retained ? Clearly not, as to the right of the plaintiff to recover one-half of the land sued for.

¶4*496John A. Meigs, the intestate of Porter Fleming, had hut two heirs; one an idiot sister, who, before and at the time of his death, and ever since, has been non compos mentis, and the inmate of an Asylum. How is it as to the other half? The only other heir was o.feme covert, who as the answer alleges, was abandoned by her husband, when the right to this property accrued, and has been ever since. Should a Court of Equity restrain the administrator from recovering her share of this land, when she could not sue for it herself, and her husband would not? Is not her equity as good, if not better than the defendant’s, who comes into a Court of Equity and asks its aid to protect his statutory title, purchasing as he did, from one, who had no title to the land, and made_no pretence even, that he was the true owner ?

¶5Should this moiety of land he recovered by the administrator, it will not be for the benefit of the husband, who had a right to sue, hut it will be settled upon the deserted wife, who, being under coverture, could not move in the matter.

¶6Situated as this woman is, it seems to us, that hex’s is the better equity of the two; and we so decide.

¶7Judgment reversed.

/27/ga/494 · .json · Public domain