Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

27 S.C.L. 252

Boies v. State

Supreme Court of South Carolina

Decided February 15, 1842

Supreme Court of South Carolina · decided 1842-02-15

Before Earle, J., at Charleston, May Term, 1841. The defendants were jointly indicted for receiving stolen góods ; pleaded not guilty, and were tried together. The verdict was, guilty as to Boies, and not guilty, as to Stuke.

Decided 1842-02-15

¶1Curia, per

Evans, J.

¶2The first, second and fourth grounds in this case, are founded on the supposition, that as the defendants were indicted for a joint offence, the proof, to authorize the conviction of either, must correspond with the allegation. On the civil side of the Court, if a joint contract be alleged, the proof must correspond; but for torts, the rule is different; a verdict may be rendered against as many as are proved to have participatedun the tort; and for those who are not guilty, the same rule prevails in the criminal Court. The indictment may charge' many, but if the proof be only against one, he may be convicted, and the others acquitted. The authority cited from 2 English Crown Cases, 257, does not, as the defendants’s counsel supposed, sustain his position. It goes no further than to maintain what no one doubts, that successive acts cannot be given in evidence under a count charging a joint act. The third ground was not. argued, and is considered as abandoned. ' The motion is refused.

We concur. J. S. Richardson, John Belton O’Neall, A. P. Butler, D. L. Wardlaw,Earle, J., absent,
/27/scl/252 · .json · Public domain