Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

273 Minn. 453

142 N.W.2d 581

Oehler v. Falstrom

Supreme Court of Minnesota

Decided May 6, 1966

Supreme Court of Minnesota · decided 1966-05-06

Relies on Netzer v. Northern Pacific Railway Co. · Chard v. Darlington

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1966-05-06

How this case has been cited

Cited by 29 later decisions — most recently July 2024 · most notably Rauenhorst v. Comm'r (2002), Marriage of Olsen v. Olsen (1997)

2 district · 23 state decisions

1001966197019801990200020102020decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

*460Rogosheske, Justice

¶1(dissenting).

¶2I cannot agree with the disposition of this appeal.

¶3At the close of plaintiff’s case in chief the only evidence tending to prove that the money was loaned was his subjective declaration that such was his intention which he first disclosed after he supplied the funds to defendants and when he demanded repayment. In my opinion, upon all of the testimony there is no evidentiary basis from which it could be reasonably inferred that the funds were either advanced at defendants’ special instance and request or that defendants, by words or conduct, expressly or impliedly promised repayment. Thus, the proof necessary to establish a prima facie case for a loan is lacking. The trial court simply concluded that plaintiff did not prove by a fair preponderance of the evidence that the transaction was a loan, and therefore the issue of whether the delivery of the funds constituted a gift is unnecessary to decide.

¶4Unlike Chard v. Darlington, 243 Minn. 489, 68 N. W. (2d) 405, plaintiff here did not have the burden of establishing ownership of personal property to make out a prima facie case of conversion but rather the burden of establishing that the transaction was a loan. To remand and direct a finding on defendants’ claim of a gift presupposes that the court erred in finding a failure on the part of plaintiff to prove his claim. If the court on remand finds the evidence also insufficient to establish a gift, as is quite likely, the disposition of this case will be unchanged unless we are holding that in that event plaintiff’s proof is sufficient as a matter of law.

¶5In my opinion, we have no choice but to affirm unless the facts of this case call for a change in the fundamental rules relating to burden of proof.1 It may be that plaintiff has a right to recover all or part of the funds supplied upon some theory other than a loan, but that question is not presented and it is not within our province to make that determination on this record.

¶6Rule 1(5), Uniform Rules of Evidence; McCormick, Evidence, § 319; Netzer v. N. P. Ry. Co. 238 Minn. 416, 57 N. W. (2d) 247.

/273/minn/453 · .json · Public domain