Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

279 N.C. 663

185 S.E.2d 174

State v. Williams

Supreme Court of North Carolina

Decided December 15, 1971

Supreme Court of North Carolina · decided 1971-12-15

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1971-12-15

How this case has been cited

Cited by 308 later decisions — most recently March 2014 · most notably State v. Monk (1975), State v. Smith (1977)

5 federal appellate · 301 state decisions

182019711980199020002010decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Justice Higgins

¶1dissenting.

¶2In the ordinary case I have favored the Federal rule which protects a defendant, when a witness for himself, from cross-examination with respect to other indictments against him. The reason for the Federal rule is that a presumption of innocence is not overcome by an indictment which is only a charge. As pointed out in the Court’s opinion, the State has been permitted to impeach by showing an indictment for a separate offense.

¶3The record in this case indicates to me the admission of the defendant that two and probably three other armed robbery cases against him are now pending in nearby communities. Under the rule the Court now adopts, a defendant may find a filling station operator alone in his place of business, hold him up, take his money, proceed to the next similar place of business, simi-larily attended by a lone operator, and continue the process ad infinitum. In each instance there are two eyewitnesses to the robbery — the victim and the robber. The latter may make a good appearance, raising a doubt as to his guilt and be acquitted. Each succeeding case becomes a repeat performance. Of course, if the robber is acquitted, the acquittal does not impeach him.

¶4*676I think the proper rule should be that the State may be able to impeach the defendant by showing a trail of indictments following his movements and if he denies the indictments, the State should be able to call witnesses who could identify him as the man who was leaving behind him a trail of robberies.

¶5Of course the time, distance, and similarity of the criminal actions should have weight in showing this course of conduct. I fear the breadth and sweep of this new rule will unduly handicap the State in its criminal prosecutions.

/279/nc/663 · .json · Public domain