Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

28 Barb. 403

Sherman v. Wells

New York Supreme Court

Decided September 20, 1858

New York Supreme Court · decided 1858-09-20

The action was brought for the purpose of charging the defendant, as a common carrier, for the value of certain bonds of the state of Michigan, intrusted to him at Buffalo, for transmission to the plaintiff at Detroit, and which he failed to deliver.

Cited by 3 later decisions — most recently December 1890

3 state decisions

Relies on Russell v. Livingston

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1858-09-20

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

By the Court, Davies, P. J.

¶1The facts are succinctly and correctly stated in the referee’s report, and the only question presented is, are the defendants liable for the loss of the bonds intrusted to them ? That the defendants are common carriers, cannot, we think, be doubted. It was settled that they were, in the case of Russell v. Livingston, in this court, (19 Barb. 346.) The judgment in that case was reversed in the court of appeals, (16 New York Rep. 515,) but on an entirely different point. The defendants being, therefore, common carriers, and there being no special contract, the parties are to be supposed to have acted with a full knowledge of their legal rights and liabilities, and must be held to the stringent rule of law which makes a carrier an insurer against all except the act of G-od and the public enemy. (Dorr v. The New Jersey Steam Navigation Co.., 1 Kern. 485.)

¶2When goods are intrusted to a carrier and not delivered according to contract, the value of the goods, with interest thereon from the day when they should have been delivered, is the measure of damages. (Sedgwick on Damages, 255.) We .think the proof fully authorized the referee to find that the bonds were of their par value, and that no injustice has been done the defendants in this respect.

¶3The judgment appealed from will therefore be affirmed, with costs.

/28/barb/403 · .json · Public domain