¶1The respondent was not entitled to be made a deby the action is the real property, and in this the respondent has no interest. Its interest is only in the question involved in the action, and this is not the interest to which section 452 refers. A consequential interest will not suffice. Barb. Parties, 488. The special term had power to direct the respondent to be made a defendant, though not required to do so by the Code provision (Bank v. Farthing, 101 N. Y. 344, 4 N. E. 734), but naturally this power ought not to have been exercised, except for sufficient reason. The papers disclose none. There is no charge of misconduct against the insured, nor does there appear to be any reason to doubt that the respondent will have a fair opportunity to protect its»interest without being a defendant. Under the circumstances, the motion should not have been granted. Davies v. Fish, 47 Hun, 314. Order reversed, with $10 costs and disbursements.
28 N.Y.S. 392
Russ v. Stratton
The Superior Court of the City of New York and Buffalo
Decided April 2, 1894
The Superior Court of the City of New York and Buffalo · decided 1894-04-02
.Actions, one by Herman Russ and others against Eliza Stratton and others and the Lawyers’ Title Insurance Company of New York, and the other by Louis E. Fraser and another against Minna Duncan and others and the Lawyers’ Title Insurance Company of New York. From an order making the title insurance company a defendant, plaintiffs appeal. Reversed.
Relies on White's Bk. of Buffalo v. . Farthing
Decided 1894-04-02