¶1The plaintiff herein brought action seeking to quiet title in some i,6oo acres of land situate in Pennington •county, S. D. His complaint is the short form prescribed by statute. The defendants Gamble, Tripp, and Ohlman joined in an answer, and pleaded an interest in the said land under and by virtue of a contract entered into by themselves and their co-defendant, whereby the defendants contracted to purchase, and plaintiff to sell, the said land in question. The defendants, after pleading the contract, allege the payment of a large sum of money thereunder, and that the further performance of the contract upon their part was excused by the plaintiff’s failure to perform his covenant contained in said contract, namely, to clear the title to said land from incumbrances and clouds thereon. Said defendants asked for the recovery of the money paid by them on the contract, and for damages suffered by them in examination of title to said land. The defendant Loffler, by his separate answer, pleaded facts practically the same as his codefendants, and, in addition, pleaded certain damages through plaintiff’s failure to carry out the contract. The plaintiff, replying to said answers, admitted the execution of contract and the payment by defendants of a certain sum thereunder, though not the amount claimed by -defendants. Under the contract, plaintiff had agreed to furnish abstracts showing a clear and tmincumbered title to the lands; and he pleaded *230that said contract was afterwards modified, so that he was allowed to pay off a certain ¡mortgage standing against said land from money to be received by him on the first and second deferred payments to be made under said contract.' Plaintiff alleged that, excepting the showing of' such mortgage incumbrance upon the abstracts, he had in all ways fulfilled the contract, and that defendants had wholly failed to live up to said contract, and that defend-, ants had repudiated said contract and attempted to rescind same. Plaintiff in his reply said that he tendered and brought into court, for the purpose of delivery to the defendants, a good and sufficient warranty deed executed by himself, and conveying said land to defendants as well as abstracts showing perfect title in plaintiff with-the exception of the mortgage above referred to. Plaintiff asked that a short time be given defendants within which to make the further payments provided by the contract, and that the court direct that the mortgage incumbrance be paid out of the money so paid into court by defendants, or, if the court so elected, plaintiff offered that he would immediately pay such incumbrance from his other funds. The cause was tried to the court without gc jury. Findings of fact and cpnclusions of law were entered in favor of plaintiff. Upon these findings and conclusions a decree was entered quieting title to the lands in the plaintiff with judgment for costs against the defendants and without any■ provision fey repay-, merit to defendants of any part of the purchase money paid by them. The defendants moved for a new trial, which motion having been denied, they have appealed to this court, from the judg-ment of the trial court and from the order denying a new trial.
¶2The respondent in his brief filed in this court under date of October 10, 1910, noted the fact that he intended later to move to strike from the record the purported bill of exceptions filed herein; but it was riot until immediately preceding the April, 1911,, term that respondent did make any such motion. Such motion was made returnable on the first day of such April term. In said motion the respondent prayed “for an order and decision that the alleged bill of exceptions, settled and allowed by the court, and transmitted to this court, be stricken from the record; that the said *231case and this appeal be not heard upon the merits upon the records as here and now pi'esented for want of necessary and material evidence and exhibits omitted from said alleged bill; that the appellant’s assignments of error be held to be insufficient to present any question to this court for review; and that the judgment of the court below be in all things affirmed, and for such other and further relief in the premises as may be just and proper.”
¶3
¶4
¶5Respondent has questioned the sufficiency of the assignments of error, and of the specifications of the particulars wherein the evidence is claimed insufficient to sustain certain findings of the trial court, as such assignments and specifications appear- in the bill of exceptions used upon motions for new trial and in the abstract on file in this court, and it must be conceded that such assignments and specifications are not as full and clear as good practice might require, but yet we think the same sufficient to fairly present for our consideration certain alleged errors of the trial court; Disregarding such purported findings of fact as are in fact mere conclusions of law, the record shows that the trial court . ■ -and in brief as follows:
¶6That plaintiff was the fee owner of the land at all times hereinafter mentioned; that the defendants claim an interest therein *233adverse to plaintiff; that on or about July 30, 1907, the parties hereto entered into the following contract:
“This contract made this 24th day of July, A. D. 1907, by and between Albert E. Bates, of the county of Pennington and state of South Dakota, party of the first part, and Gilbert D. Eoffler, Robert J. Gamble, Robert B. Tripp, and J. W. Ohlman, of Yankton county, South Dakota, parties of the second part, witnesseth: That the party of the first-part hereby agrees to sell, and do sell, to the parties of the second part, and the parties of the second part hereby agree to buy from the party of the first part, the following described real estate situate in the county of Pennington, and the state of South Dakota, and described as fol-. lows, to-vpt: [Here follows a description of land.] The agreed purchase price of said land is seventeen thousand six hundred dollars ($17,600.00) which the parties of the second part agree to pay to the party of the first part as follows, to-wit: $3,200.00 upon the execution and delivery of this contract and agreement. $4,800.00 on or before the first of December, 1907, with interest at 6 per cent, per annum from date. $4,800.00 on or before March 1, 1908, with interest at 6 per cent, per annum from date. $4,800.00 on or before three (3) years from the date of this contract with interest at the rate of 7 per cent, per annum from date.
“It is further agreed that the party of the first part shall forthwith, and at his expense, furnish and deliver to the parties of the second part an abstract of title to each of the 160-acre tracts, or less amount of land, of the premises above described showing a perfect title in all the lands covered by this contract and agreement, clear and free of all incumbrances except taxes thereon for the year 1907, which taxes the parties of the second part agree to pay, and also subsequent taxes duly assessed against said property.
“It is further agreed that the party of the first part will upon demand, at any time within three years from the date of this contract, execute and deliver to the parties of the second part a good and sufficient warranty deed for the whole or any part of said land provided the parties of the second part shall at the time of *234receiving said deed or deeds have paid or pay to the parties of the first part at least $11.00 for each and every acre of lands then or previously conveyed by deed by the parties of the first part to1 the parties of the second part.
“It is the intention of the contract and agreement that the parties of the second part must pay for and receive deeds for all of said lands within three years, or at the expiration of three years from the date of this contract, and that they may receive a deed or deeds to all or any part of said lands at any time before the expiration of said three years upon paying for the lands so deeded at least $11.00 per acre.
“It is further mutually understood and agreed by and between the parties to this contract that .in case of any sale or sales by the parties of the second part of all or any tracts of land herein-before mentioned and covered by this contract that the cash payment received thereon as a part of the consideration thereof on-said sale shall be paid over by said parties of the second part to-the parties of the first part, and the same shall be applied on this contract and credited upon the first deferred payment falling due thereafter. (And any note or notes or mortgage that may be received and taken by the parties of the second part on any tract or tracts of land covered by this contract as a part consideration of the sale thereof shall be assigned and turned over by the said parties of the second part to the parties of the first part, and the amount thereof shall be indorsed and credited upon the, last payment specified in this agreement, provided that said mortgages or mortgage shall not exceed in amount two-thirds of the purchase price of any of the said tract or tracts, and that the same shall draw interest at 7 per cent, per annum payable annually. Attached to and made a part of this contract by permission of Albert E. Bates, party of -the first part, and G. D. Loffler, representing the parties of the second part. Signed, sealed, and delivered in my presence this 30th day of July, 1907. Albert E. Bates. G. D. Goffier, Aimer E- Weeks. [Seal.] Notary Public, S. D.)
“In witness whereof the parties hereto have hereunto set their hands and seals the day and year first above written. Witnesses. *235Victor T. Jepson. [Signed by] Albert E. Bates. [Seal.] Gilbert D. Eoffler. [Seal.] Robert J. Gamble. [Seal.] Robert B. Tripp. [Seal.] J. W. Olilman. [Seal.]”
¶7That the plaintiff duly performed all the conditions of the contract upon his part. That defendants Gamble, Tripp, and Ohlman paid $1,600 on said contract on or about July 30, 1907. That the defendants have never paid any further sum, and have wholly refused and neglected to perform or comply with said contract in any particular, and on October 31, 1907, wholly repudiated the said contract and notified plaintiff they would not perform the same, and made, or attempted to make, a rescission thereof. That plaintiff furnished abstracts of title showing perfect title in him, with exception of one mortgage securing debt of $8,000. That defendants returned the abstracts claiming sundry alleged defects therein, and asking that such defects be cured. That thereafter, and before October 25, 1907, the plaintiff caused all such alleged defects to be cured, and delivered to defendants abstracts showing-perfect title other than the said mortgage incumbrance. That on or about October 31, 1907, defendants returned the abstracts with the written opinion of attorneys to effect that all defects in title had been removed except said mortgage and accompanied such letter with a notice repudiating contract and attempting its rescission. That at time of making contract, and subsequently thereto, it was understood and agreed that the said mortgage incumbrance could be paid out of the purchase money to be paid under said contract, and need not be satisfied of record until after the making of the third payment. That defendants expressly waived any objection to said title owing to such mortgage. That defendants' objections to said titles and abstracts, and that said notice of rescission, were not made in good faith, but were made for the reason that defendants were unable or unwilling to make the «payments called for by said contract. That immediately upon receipt of the notice of rescission, to-wit, on November 8/1907, plaintiff gave defendants- prompt notice that he had been performing and intended to perform the contract, and would insist upon performance by defendants. That plaintiff, at same time, notified defend *236ants that it was understood and agreed that the mortgage could be paid out of the purchase money, but that, nevertheless, if the existence of the mortgage was an injury to defendants, he would have if immediately satisfied and released,* and that any other alleged defects would be cured within the time provided by contract if same were not already cured. That no- demand was ever made for the release of said mortgage. That plaintiff brought into court abstracts showing perfect titles to said lands in plaintiff, excepting such mortgage, and also a sufficient deed of warranty to be delivered to defendants upon their complying with said contract within a time to be fixed by the court. That plaintiff stipulated in court that the mortgage could be paid from the said purchase money, or plaintiff would immediately pay the same out of his own funds. Then followed a finding relating to defendant Loffler’s claim for damages, but which in the view we take of the case becomes immaterial.
¶8Upon these findings the court concluded that defendants were not entitled to any relief whatsoever, and, without even giving them an opportunity to pay up’ the balance due under the contract and take the deed, the learned trial court entered a decree quieting title in plaintiff and giving plaintiff judgment for costs.
¶9
¶10We do not want to be understood as holding that the findings of the trial court are sustained by the evidence. We are unable to discover one word of evidence sustaining many such findings.
¶11
¶12It is therefore clear that, with the exception of defendant Boffler, none of the parties hereto were in any wise acting except in the best of good faith, and none of them were knowingly or infentionally in default.
¶13