Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

28 Tex. 625

Juaraqui v. State

Texas Supreme Court

Decided December 15, 1866

Texas Supreme Court · decided 1866-12-15

The ease was tried before Hon. Edmund J. Davis, one of the district judges. The defendant was indicted for perjury under the 287th Article of the Code. The indictment failed to charge that the accused deliberately and willfully swore falsely, hut attempted to use equivalent words. There was a motion to quash, which was overruled, and the defendant convicted, whereupon he appealed, and the case turned upon the sufficiency of the indictment.

Cited by 2 later decisions — most recently May 1968

2 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1866-12-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Wheeler, C. J.

¶1—The indictment does not pursue the statutory definition of the offense, or use the words which the statute employs to describe it. (O. & W. Dig., p. 49, Art. 287.) The indictment ought to charge that the defendant “deliberately and willfully” swore falsely. It is always safer to use those words which the legislature has deemed most appropriate to describe the offense than to undertake to substitute others of equivalent meaning.

¶2We think the indictment insufficient, in that it does not aver that the defendant swore falsely.

¶3«The falsity of the statement ought to appear by averment, and not left to be adduced by argument and intendment. (Thomas v. The Commonwealth, 2 Rob., 795; State v. Garland, 3 Dev., 114.)

¶4The conclusion that the defendant did “falsely, wickedly, willfully, and corruptly, in manner and form aforesaid, commit willful and corrupt perjury,” being matter of deduction from the previous averments, cannot supply the want of averments essential to the proper and legal description of the offense.

¶5We think the defect indicated fatal to the indictment, and this disjDenses with the necessity of noticing other points and grounds of reversal relied on in argument.

¶6The judgment is reversed, and the cause

¶7Remanded.

/28/tex/625 · .json · Public domain