Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

29 Ala. 313

Mosser v. Mosser

Supreme Court of Alabama

Decided June 15, 1856

Supreme Court of Alabama · decided 1856-06-15

<p>[BILI. IN EQUITY FOB DIVORCE ON GROUND OF ADULTERY.]</p> <p>1. Adultery may be committed with slave. — Adultery, as the term is used in the statute which makes it a ground of divorce, (Code, § 1961,) may he committed by sexual intercourse with a slave.</p> <p>2. Answer on oath. — The defendant, not being required to answer on oath, cannot, by swearing to his answer, claim any advantage, nor demand fuller proof.</p> <p>3. Proof may be circumstantial. — To authorize a divorce on the ground of adultery, it is not nec.essary that there should be direct proof of the fact, but it may be inferred from circumstances.</p> <p>i. Sufficiency of proof. — On bill filed by the wife for a divorce, on the ground that her husband, during- her absence from home, committed adultery with a negro girl, complainant’s only witness, who had acted as housekeeper for defendant during Lis wife’s absence, testified, that he fondled about the girl, and seemed very fond of her company ; that she saw the girl go into his room one night at eight o’clock, when the door was shut-to, and there was no light in the room, — heard their voices in conversation, and heard defendant say, ‘lie down’; that the girl had not come out of the room at two o’clock, when she (witness) quit watching; that she saw the girl, on several mornings, come out of the room with the defendant; and that, on several occasions, after he had left his room, his bed bore the impression of two persons having slept in it. On the part of the defendant, it was proved, that he was at the time under medical treatment for an eruption onhislegs, which were much swollen and inflamed, and which required the application of poultices several times a day ; that the girl was the only servant about the house ; and that, on one occasion, at the request of complainant’s witness, he had severely whipped the girl. Held, (Stone, X, dissenting,) that the evidence was not sufficient to justify a divorce.</p> <p>5. Costs. — The decree of the chancellor, granting a divorce to the wife, having been reversed on error, and the evidence held insufficient, the costs of the appellate court were imposed on the next friend of the wife, and the costs of the court below on the husband.</p>

Relies on Gray v. Gray · State v. Crowley · Collins v. State

Cited in Bouvier (1914)’s definition of “Adultery” · Cyclopedic (1922)’s definition of “Adultery”

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1856-06-15

How this case has been cited

Cited by 11 later decisions — most recently November 1936

11 state decisions

30185618601870188018901900191019201930decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

STONE, J.

¶11. Slaves, although property, and free persons of color, are, under our system, regarded as persons for many purposes. — See Code of Alabama, § 2, ¶ 4; § 3805, and others. Crimes may be perpetrated against them by white persons, and the punishment in such cases is little less severe than for offenses of similar grade against white persons. — Code, tit. 1, ch. 2, art. 7, p. 591. They are reasonable creatures in being,” cared-for alike by our laws, and by the commonest dictates of humanity. Section 1961 of the Code declares, that “the court of chancery has power to divorce persons from the bonds of matrimony, in favor of either party, for adultery.” The question is presented, can this offense be committed by sexual connection with a slave? Without announcing what *317would be our decision, if the question were presented under section 3281 of the Code, we think the bill in this case sufficiently charges adultery, as contemplated by the statute. Words in a statute are presumed to be used in their popular sense, unless a different intention appear. — Thurman v. The State, 18 Ala. 276. There is nothing in this part of the Code, which indicates a different intention ; and we hold, therefore, that the legislature intended to give relief in all cases of “ unfaithfulness of a married person to the marriage bid.”— Smitherman v. The State, 27 Ala. 23.

¶22. The appellant was not required by the law to swear to his answer ; and he cannot claim any advantage, or demand fuller proof, by reason of such unauthorized oath. — Moyler v. Moyler, 11 Ala. 621 ; Hughes v. Hughes, 19 Ala. 307.

¶33. A respectable author, Shelford on Marriage and Divorce, p. 405, has well said, “Adultery, being an act of darkness and of great secrecy, can hardly be proved by any direct means and “ that presumptive evidence alone is sufficient proof.” The same author says, quoting from Lord Stowell, “ It is a fundamental rule of evidence upon this subject, that it is not necessary to prove the direct fact of adultery.” — lb. “ The only general rule that can be laid down on the subject, is, that the circumstances must be such as would lead the guarded discretion of a reasonable and just man to the conclusion.” — Shelf, on Marriage and Divorce, p. 406. In one case, it was held, that “ adultery may be inferred -from the-general cohabitation of the parties, without proof of particular facts, although the parties have separate beds.” — Loveden v. Loveden, 2 Hagg. Cons. R. 4. The court, says Lord Stowell, “ will judge of facts as other men of discernment,, exercising a sound and sober judgment on circumstances that are duly proved before them.” — See, also, Poynter' on Marriage and Divorce, 188-9. In our own court,, the subject has been under discussion. In Richardson v. Richardson, 4 Porter, 467, Justice Henry G-oldthwaite- announced the rule, that “ the fact is inferred from circumstances, that lead to it by fair inference as a necessary conclusion,” The question came again before the court in, Collins. v. The State, 14 Ala. 608, upon an indictment for adultery ; and the court held the conviction right, though Sounded an circumstances, *318without proof of the direct fact. — See, also, Glaze v. The State, 9 Ala. 283 ; Crowley v. The State, 13 Ala. 172.

¶44. I think the charge in this case is sufficiently sustained by the testimony, but my brothers think it insufficient to justify the inference that ■ adultery was committed — that the circumstances do not “ lead to it by fair inference, as a necessary conclusion;” but that they are all susceptible of a reasonable interpretation, consistent with the innocence of Mr. Mosser. — Richardson v. Richardson, supra.

¶5The decree of the chancellor, except as to costs, is reversed, and a decree here rendered, dismissing the complainant’s bill. Let the costs in the court below.be paid by appellant, and the costs of this court- by the next friend of appellee.— Gray v. Gray, 15 Ala. 779.

/29/ala/313 · .json · Public domain