Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

29 Ill. App. 268

Gooch v. Tobias

Appellate Court of Illinois

Decided November 23, 1888

Appellate Court of Illinois · decided 1888-11-23

<p>Trespass—Instructions.</p> <p>1. This court reverses a verdict for the defendant in an action of trespass for destroying certain goods, on the ground that instructions given for the defendant call for a higher degree of proof than is required in civil cases.</p> <p>2. The law does not require the plaintiff to “satisfy” or “ convince ” the jury by a preponderance of evidence in such cases.</p>

Cited by 2 later decisions — most recently October 1918

2 state decisions

Relies on Ruff v. Jarrett · Graves v. Colwell · Stratton v. Central City Horse Railway Co.

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1888-11-23

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Wall, P. J.

¶1This was an action of trespass for destroying certain goods of the plaintiff. The verdict was for the defendant and judgment was rendered accordingly, a motion for a new trial having been overruled.

¶2The court gave the following instructions at the instance of defendant:

“The court instructs the jury that, while circumstantial evidence is legal and competent in this case, vet in order to make his case by circumstantial evidence, plaintiff must have proved such circumstances as to -satisfy the jury by a preponderance of the evidence that the defendant committed the wrongful act charged.
“The court instructs th-e jury that if they believe from the evidence that the defendant, John M. Tobias, or some other person, destroyqd the goods of the plaintiff, then in that event the jury should return a verdict of not guilty, unless the jury are convinced by a preponderance of the evidence in the case that the defendant, John M. Tobias, is guilty.”

¶3These instructions call for a higher degree of proof than the law requires in order to warrant a recovery in civil cases, and in the light of the following decisions of the Supreme Court, it was error to give them: Herrick v. Gray, 83 Ill. 85; Graves v. Caldwell, 90 Ill. 612; Protection Life Ins. Co. v. Dell, 91 Ill. 174; Ruff v. Jarrett, 94 Ill. 475; Stratton v. Central City Horse Ry. Co., 95 Ill. 25.

¶4The evidence was such that it is impossible to say the plaintiff was not unduly prejudiced by this action of the court. The judgment will be reversed and the cause remanded.

¶5Reversed and rema/nded.

/29/illapp/268 · .json · Public domain