Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

29 N.H. 306

Frost v. Martin

Superior Court of New Hampshire

Decided December 15, 1854

Superior Court of New Hampshire · decided 1854-12-15

Assumpsit, for $250, money had and received and paid, laid out and expended. In April, 1849, A. Staples gave a note, signed by himself, D. Pray, and T. G. Morse, for $455, payable to S. Lock, J. A. Smiley, and T. Shapleigh, or order, in ninety days, with interest. A few months afterwards, Lock, in whose hands the note then was, made a sale of it to the defendant, and delivered it to him, receiving the principal thereof in full.

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1854-12-15

How this case has been cited

Cited by 5 later decisions — most recently December 1902

5 state decisions

20185418601870188018901900decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Gilchrist, C. J.

¶1Staples, Pray, and Morse, made a note for $455, payable to Lock, Smiley, and Shapleigh, in ninety days. Lock, having the note, sold it to the defendant, after it was due, receiving the principal. Lock and Smiley then indorsed it. Shapleigh, not knowing of - this, received $200 of Staples on the note. Afterwards, the defendant sold the note to the plaintiff, and received payment therefor. When the note was paid to the plaintiff, he was obliged to allow the $200 paid to Shapleigh, and this suit is brought to recover that sum of the defendant.

¶2It was admitted that the $200 was properly allowed by the plaintiff as a payment which he could not resist. The question made was, whether the defendant was legally liable for that sum to the plaintiff.

¶3It appears from the case that the plaintiff was told, both by the defendant and Shapleigh, that $200 had been paid *316on the note by Staples, and which Shapleigh offered to return, on learning that the defendant had bought the note ; but Staples said he might keep it on other claims he owed Shapleigh. The plaintiff then bought the note, saying he did not care for the receipt, as it was given after the sale of the note.

¶4Morse claimed to have the $200 allowed on the note, saying that he received the receipt the day after it was given.

¶5The court declined to instruct the jury that if they believed the payment was not in law a payment of the note, and the sale to the plaintiff was made with this belief, &c., he might recover; and this instruction was correct. The jury are not to say whether this was in law a payment.

¶6The court were right in instructing the jury that if the plaintiff, knowing all the facts, bought the note at his own risk, he could not recover.

¶7The court were also right in saying that it was not material that the plaintiff should know the particular terms of the receipt, if he knew it was for that sum received on the note.

¶8The conversation between the defendant and Morse does not' seem material to the rights of these parties. It is merely that Morse said the $200 ought to be allowed on'the note.

¶9The omission by the court to mention the manner in which the $200 was obtained, is no ground of exception. How far the court will go in stating the facts, is matter of discretion; and if it were not, it was too late after verdict to except, for a matter which might have been set right at the time, if the counsel had suggested it.

¶10Judgment on the verdict

/29/nh/306 · .json · Public domain