Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

299 Ark. 50

Delafield v. Lewis

Supreme Court of Arkansas

Decided May 30, 1989

Supreme Court of Arkansas · decided 1989-05-30

Applies AR 28 § 28-40-103

Relies on Morton v. Tullgren · Horn v. Horn · Sims v. Schavey

Decided 1989-05-30

Steele, Hays, Justice,

¶1dissenting. Our cases give us two options: we can reverse the trial court, follow Morton v. Tullgren, 263 Ark. 69, 563 S.W.2d 422 (1978), a position rejected by a majority of courts, and thus defeat the certain intent of the testatrix in the disposition of her estate. Or we can follow Horn v. Horn, Administrator, 226 Ark. 27, 287 S.W.2d 586 (1956), and Sims v. Schavey, 234 Ark. 166, 351 S.W.2d 145 (1961), affirm the trial court, uphold the will and, I believe, achieve exactly the result intended by the legislature in the enactment of Ark. Code Ann. § 28-40-103(c). The latter course seems more appropriate to me.

Holt, C.J., and Hickman, J., join in this dissent.
/299/ark/50 · .json · Public domain