Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

3 Abb. Pr. 226

Van Alstrand v. House

New York Supreme Court

Decided September 15, 1856

New York Supreme Court · decided 1856-09-15

Application to open a default upon a motion to change the place of trial. The defendant formerly moved, at a special term held by Mr. Justice Shankland, to change the place of trial of this action from Chemung to Saratoga county, which motion was granted by default. The plaintiff now moved to open the default upon an affidavit showing he had a greater number of witnesses in Chemung than the defendant had in Saratoga county.

Decided 1856-09-15

Balcom, J.

¶1plaintiff’s attorney should have appeared before Judge Shankland and asked him to postpone the hear*227ing of the motion until he could obtain the plaintiff’s affidavit to oppose it. He offers no excuse for not doing so, except that he thought it useless to go before Judge Shankland without the plaintiff’s affidavit to oppose the motion on its merits. If the plaintiff’s attorney had presented his affidavit to Judge Shankland, showing that he had used due diligence to procure the plaintiff’s affidavit, and had been unable to obtain it, the judge could' have ordered that the motion stand over for hearing at some future special term, to enable the plaintiff’s affidavit to oppose it to be procured. He was the proper judge to determine whether the plaintiff’s attorney had a good excuse for not being ready then to oppose the motion on its merits. Had he ordered that the hearing of it should be postponed, the terms of the postponement would have been fixed by him.

¶2The motion to open the default must be denied, with $10 costs, for the unexcused neglect of the plaintiff’s attorney to appear and ask for a postponement of the hearing of the original motion.

/3/abbpr/226 · .json · Public domain