Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

3 Ala. App. 519

Shannon & Co. v. McElroy

Alabama Court of Appeals

Decided December 19, 1911

Alabama Court of Appeals · decided 1911-12-19

Heard before Hon. T. L. Sowell. Assumpsit by W. P. McElroy against Shannon & Company, and another. Judgment for plaintiff and defendant appeals. The 3rd plea is as follows: There is no consideration for the account sued on. The court erred in striking plea 3. — Olosky v. Enslen> 103 Ala. 97; 3 Ala. 316. It set up a defense which was required to be specially pleaded. — 4 Mayf. 484. The court erred in failing to grant defendant’s motion for a new trial.- — S'O; Ry.

Relies on Alabama Gold Life Insurance v. Mobile Mutual Insurance · Matthews v. Turner · Robinson v. Windham

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Affirmed · Decided 1911-12-19

How this case has been cited

Cited by 5 later decisions — most recently March 1954

5 state decisions

2019111920193019401950decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

WALKER, P. J.

¶1The defendant was not prejudiced by the action of the court in striking his third plea. The *520defense of want of consideration was available to him under his plea of the general issue. In assumpsit, under the general issue, any matter which shows that the plaintiff never had any cause of action, or that, ex aequo et bono, he ought not to recover, may be given in evidence. That plea puts upon the plaintiff the burden of proving every fact which is an essential constituent of his cause of action.

¶2The express or implied promise upon which such action is based requires a consideration for its legal support and existence; and the plaintiff cannot maintain his action when the evidence shows that the promise counted on was without consideration.—Matthews v. Turner, 2 Stew. & P. 239; Robinson v. Windham, 9 Port. 397; Ala. Gold Life Ins. Co. v. Mobile Mutual Ins. Co., 81 Ala. 329, 1 South. 561; 4 Cyc. 353; 2 Ency. of Pleading & Pr. 1029.

¶3In view of the conflicting evidence set out in the bill of exceptions, the assignments of error based upon the refusal of the court to give the general affirmative charge requested by the defendant, and to grant his motion for a new trial, are clearly without merit.

¶4Affirmed.

/3/alaapp/519 · .json · Public domain