Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

3 Denio 77

Shove v. Raynor

New York Supreme Court

Decided May 15, 1846

New York Supreme Court · decided 1846-05-15

P., to review a judgment of tha court reversing on certiorari, a judgment rendered by a justice of the peace. The suit before the justice was by Raynor v. Shove. Issue having been joined, it was tried by a jury who found a verdict for the defendant.

Decided 1846-05-15

By the Court, Beardsley, J.

¶1The manner of receiving the verdict was irregular. The plaintiff, if he chose to do so, might suffer a nonsuit by refusing to appear. This was an important right of which the justice could not deprive him by recognizing the answer of a person unknown, as an appearance for the plaintiff. The justice was bound to see that the plaintiff appeared in person or by some person duly authorized, before he received the verdict. (2 R. S. 244, § 110; Id. p. 246, § 119; Baum v. Tarpenny, 3 Hill, 75.) We cannot intend that this unknown person was the plaintiff, or any one authorized to appear for him. Appearance, in such a case, is much more than a mere matter of form, and the return should show the fact that the plaintiff duly appeared, or the verdict will be deemed irregular.

¶2The judgment of the common pleas, reversing that of the justice, was correct, and should be affirmed.

¶3Judgment affirmed. .

/3/denio/77 · .json · Public domain