Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

3 Edw. Ch. 328

Johnston v. Bloomer

New York Court of Chancery

Decided July 29, 1839

New York Court of Chancery · decided 1839-07-29

Motion to set aside an order, referring exceptions taken to an answer. An answer to a supplemental bill was filed on the sixteenth day of May; and served on the same day. Exceptions to it were taken, filed and served on the twenty-ninth of the same May. An order to refer the exceptions to a master was entered on the twenty-fourth of June following.

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently April 1892

1 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1839-07-29

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

The Vice-Chancellor :

¶1The defendant has taken no step which at all recognizes the validity of the order of reference, nor has he so delayed giving notice of this motion as to have waived his right to object to the order. The reason why a delay operates as a waiver does not exist in this case. If the complainants had been lulled into a belief of the regularity of their order and taken proceedings consequent upon it, while the defendants’ solicitor had a knowledge of the irregularity and apparently acquiesced and induced the complainants to go on and incur an expense, with a view of afterwards setting their proceedings aside, then, in such a case it would be manifestly unjust to allow the proceedings to be set aside and the delay would be held to be a waiver: 1 Hoff. Ch. Pr. 417. But it is questionable whether here is not more than an irreg- ■ ular order ; whether, by the 51st rule, it is not a nullity. If so, there can be no waiver, by delay, in moving to set it aside: lb.

¶2The next question is whether, upon the affidavit of the complainants’ solicitor, he can still have the benefit of the order *330saved to him on this motion, upon terms ? I think he cannot; and that any relief from his own laches, which he may wish to ask for, must be the subject of a distinct motion on his part." Order : that the order of reference of the exceptions be set aside ; with costs of this motion to be taxed.

/3/edwch/328 · .json · Public domain