Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

3 Ill. 28

Ballentine v. McDowell

Illinois Supreme Court

Decided December 15, 1839

Illinois Supreme Court · decided 1839-12-15

This was an action of assumpsit commenced by McDowell against Ballentine, in the Wabash Circuit Court, for the use and occupation of a ferry and ferry landing. The cause was heard at the April term, 1839, and judgment rendered for the plaintiff for $ 125 and costs.

Decided 1839-12-15

Smith, Justice,

¶1delivered the opinion of the Court :

¶2This is an action for the use and occupation of land. The cause was submitted to the Court, on evidence, without the intervention of a jury, and judgment rendered for the plaintiff in the Circuit Court.

¶3From the bill of exceptions it is very clear, on the evidence stated in it, that there is nothing to support the judgment. It does not appear that the relation of landlord and tenant existed between the parties to the action. An offer to hire, and a refusal to pay rent, negatives the idea of a contract, instead of supporting one by inference ; besides there is no proof how long the party occupied the premises, nor was there any promise to pay any specific sum for rent, nor has the value of the use of the ground been shown. So far as there is evidence of value, the defendant has shown it to be fifty dollars per annum, under an arrangement with a third person under whom the defendant below claimed to use the premises and ferry.

¶4We cannot doubt that the judgment should be reversed with costs.

¶5Judgment reversed.

/3/ill/28 · .json · Public domain