Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

3 Mass. 121

Howell v. Freeman

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · decided 1807-07-15

<p>This was an action pending in the county of Cumberland, in which the only question brought before the Court was, whether Frye was trustee of Freeman. This question was argued at the last May term at Portland, and the action was continued nisi foi advisement.</p> <p>From the facts disclosed by Frye, in his answers to interroga tories, it appeared that at a Court of Common Pleas [ * 122 ] * holden on the third Tuesday of February, Anno Domini 1805, an action of covenant broken was pending, in which Freeman was plaintiff, and Frye defendant; that, at that term, the parties entered into a rule to submit all demands between them to certain referees, and that judgment should be entered on their report, and execution issue accordingly; that the referees, after hearing the parties, agreed on their report on the 14th day of May following, in which they awarded Frye to pay to Freeman 602 dollars, 84 £ cents, with costs; that the report of the referees was returned to the next Court of Common Pleas holden on the third Tuesday of June; that on the twenty-fourth day of the same May, Howell sued Freeman, and attached all his goods, effects, and credits, in the hands of Frye as his trustee, by a writ returnable on the same third Tuesday of June ; that, at that term, Howell prosecuted his action against Freeman, and that Freeman had judgment against Frye on the report of the referees; that, on the eleventh day of July, Freeman sued out his execution against Frye, which was satisfied on the twenty-second of the same month by extending the same on Fiye’s lands; and that Frye had no goods, effects, or credits, of Freeman in his hands at the commencement of this writ, unless the sum reported as aforesaid by the referees should be deemed credits liable to Howell’s attachment.</p>

Relies on Minot v. Prescott · Eunson v. Healy · Kidd v. Shepherd

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1807-07-15

How this case has been cited

Cited by 8 later decisions — most recently November 1951

8 state decisions

201807181018201830184018501860187018801890190019101920193019401950decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1At this term the opinion of the Court was delivered by

Parsons, C. J.

¶2[who, after reciting the facts as before stated, proceeded.]

¶3That the sum reported by the referees was a credit of Freeman’s in Frye’s hands is very clear, as it was a debt due before, but not liquidated until the report. But whether this credit was so situated as to be the subject of Howell’s attachment, is the great question.

¶4The eighth section of the act, which authorizes the attachment of credits, provides that the taking of the goods, effects, and credits, out of the hands of the trustee, pursuant to that statute, shall discharge him against all suits and demands of the principal; and, if sued, he may plead the general issue, and give that statute in evidence.

¶5It is the design of the statute, and manifestly just, that the trustee shall not be twice charged for the same credit, once *106[*124] *by the attaching creditor, and again by his principal. The credit, therefore, liable to this attachment, must be so situated, that, if it be taken by the attaching creditor, the trustee may legally defend himself, when called on by the principal.

¶6In the present case, before the attachment, a suit to compel pay ment was pending, a rule of reference had been entered into, in which the parties had agreed that judgment should be entered according to the report, and the referees had agreed on their report. In this state of the action, no day for pleading remained for the trustee, and the law furnished him with no legal defence against the principal’s demand of judgment. The principal being entitled to judgment, his execution was properly sued out and satisfied. The debt consequently due him from the trustee was, at the time of Howell’s attachment, so situated, that he could not defend himself against paying it to Freeman: it is not, therefore, a credit in the hands of the trustee subject to this attachment (2).

¶7The trustee must be discharged and have his costs.

¶8 [Locke vs. Tippets & Trustee, 7 Mass. 149.—Foster vs. Jones, 15 Mass. 185.— Gridley vs. Harraden, 14 Mass. 496.—Thorndike vs. De Wolf, 6 Pick. 120.—Kidd vs Shepherd, 4 Mass. 238.—Eunson vs Healy Trustee, 2 Mass. 32.—Ed.]

/3/mass/121 · .json · Public domain