Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

3 N.H. 348

M'Crillis v. How

Superior Court of New Hampshire

Decided February 15, 1826

Superior Court of New Hampshire · decided 1826-02-15

Assumpsit upon a note, dated February 21, 1823, for §21,92, made by the defendant and payable to the plaintiff or order. There was also a count upon an account for medicines and visits, as a physician, amounting to $21,92. The cause was submitted to the decision of the court, upon the following facts. The plaintiff did the services, and furnished the medicines, mentioned in the second count; but at the time, the defendant was an infant under the age of twenty-one years.

Cited by 2 later decisions — most recently June 1936

2 state decisions

Relies on Markle v. Hatfield

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1826-02-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

By the court.

¶1It has long been settled, that no action can be maintained against an infant, upon a promissory note. The reason assigned is, because, if the note was held to he valid, the infant would, when the note was in the hands of a bona fide endorsee, be precluded from disputing the original debt. Chitt. on Bill. 24.—1 D. & E. 40, Freeman vs. Hurst.—3 Caines' Rep. 322, Van Winkle vs. Mitcham.—10 John. 33, Swazey vs. The adm'r. of Vanderheyden.—2 Starkie 36, Ingledew vs. Douglas.—Campbell 552, Williamson vs. Watts.—Carthew 160, Williams vs. Harrison et a.

¶2The plaintiff then cannot recover upon his first count. — - But we see no objection to a judgment in his favor, on the second count. A void note, given to balance an account, is no satisfaction. 2 Johns. 455, Markle vs. Hatfield.—1 Esp. N. P. R. 5.—6 D. & E. 52, Puckford vs. Maxwell.—1 N. H. R. 281.—3 Brod. & Bing. 295.—7 Taunton 311, Hickling vs. Hardy.—4 East 147.

¶3Judgment for the plaintiff.

/3/nh/348 · .json · Public domain