Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

3 S.C.L. 271

Connolly v. Stewart

Supreme Court of South Carolina

Decided May 15, 1803

Supreme Court of South Carolina · decided 1803-05-15

Motion to reverse the decision of Johnson, J., in this case, in Charleston district; upon the following point: R. B., being in. debted to the plaintiff by bond, dated 1709, for securing the payment thereof, mortgaged a certain house built upon a leasehold estate. The mortgage w; s recorded in August, 1800. in the office of the Secretary of Slate.

Decided 1803-05-15

Sed per Curiam.(Bay, Johnson, Trezevant, and Brevard, Justices, absent, Guimke, J. and Watiks, J.)

¶1It seems to have been the policy of the act, to require that mortgages con. ceruing real property should be recorded in one public office; and mortgages concerning personal property in another public office. The act, in making this distinction, seems to have had respect to the thing or subject mortgaged, and not to the interest or title of the mortgagor, in, or to the thing. In this case, the thing, or property mortgaged, was land. It was a house and lot in possession of the mortgagor. It appears that the mortgagor was not entitled to the absolute property : he had only a term for years in the land. But the quantity of interest, does not alter the case. *273It is not the quantity of interest, but the nature of the property, whether land, or personal estate, that must decide in which office the mortgage shall be recorded.

Ward, for the motion. Cheves, contra,

¶2Decision of the district court affirmed.

/3/scl/271 · .json · Public domain