Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

30 Cal. 190

Boulware v. Craddock

California Supreme Court

Decided July 15, 1866

California Supreme Court · decided 1866-07-15

<p>Demand on Sheriff for Property Wrongfully Taken.—If a Sheriff, by virtue of an execution, seizes the property of a person other than the judgment debtor, whether by mistake or design, it is not necessary for the owner of the property thus seized to make a demand on the Sheriff before commencing suit.</p>

Relies on Acker v. Campbell · Ledley v. Hays · Daumiel v. Gorham

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1866-07-15

How this case has been cited

Cited by 10 later decisions — most recently January 1915

9 state decisions

30186618701880189019001910decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

By the Court, Shafter, J.:

¶1In an action against a Sheriff for a seizure and conversion of the plaintiff’s property, taken under process against a third person, a demand upon the defendant prior to the bringing of the suit is not necessary to a recovery. The Sheriff having misapplied his process, and whether by mistake or design will make no difference, stands in the position of every other trespasser, and is liable to an action the instant the trespass is committed. The circumstance that the property.was in the possession of the execution debtor at the date of the seizure amounts to nothing except upon proof of fraud or commixture. The rule of the common law is correctly stated in Ledley v. Hays, 1 Cal. 160, and the correctness of that decision is impliedly recognized in Daumiel v. Gorham, 6 Cal. 44. The statement of facts in Taylor v. Seymour, 6 Cal. 512, is imperfect; but if that case is to be understood as laying down a different rule, then we prefer to follow Ledley v. Hays. (See also Codman v. Freeman, 3 Cush. 314; and Ackee v. Campbell, 23 Wend. 371.)

¶2The judgment is reversed, and the Court below is directed to render judgment upon the findings in favor of the plaintiff.

¶3Mr. Justice Rhodes expressed no opinion.

/30/cal/190 · .json · Public domain