Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

30 La. 881

State v. Johnson

Supreme Court of Louisiana

Decided April 15, 1878

Supreme Court of Louisiana · decided 1878-04-15

<p>The State must affirmatively show that the confession made by an accused was voluntary. A confession made by a prisoner under any promise of advantage to him. in consequence of it, must be rejected.</p>

Decided 1878-04-15

¶1The opinion of the court was delivered by

Spencer, J.

¶2The only question presented by the defendants on this their appeal from a conviction.of breaking and entering, etc., and grand larceny, is as to the admissibility of evidence of the confession made by one of them to an officer in charge.

¶3The bill of exceptions, as prepared by defendant’s counsel, recites that in answer to the question whether he had made any promises to the prisoner, by stating to him that he would be permitted to turn State’s evidence, the officer replied, “ I did.” The district attorney adds that his recollection of the answer was that “ he may have said to him that he might be used as a State loitness.” The judge adds that his attention was not drawn to the officer’s answer particularly at the time, and his recollection is not distinct, but thinks the district attorney’s version is .correct.

¶4In our opinion either version suffices to show that the confession •ought not to have been allowed to go to the jury.

¶5The prosecution must show affirmatively that the confession was voluntary and not made under improper influences. State vs. Nelson, 3 An. 499. The words used by the officer clearly indicate a promise of .advantage to the prisoner in consequence of his confession. Archbold, 7th ed. p. 413; Wharton, p. 686; Boyd vs. State, 2 Humph. 390. The evidence should have been excluded on the showing made.

¶6It is therefore ordered, adjudged, and decreed that the verdict and sentence appealed from be set aside and reversed, and that this cause be remanded as to all the defendants for a new trial according to law.

/30/la/881 · .json · Public domain