Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

300 N.W.2d 834

Erdle v. Dorgan

North Dakota Supreme Court

Decided December 19, 1980

North Dakota Supreme Court · decided 1980-12-19

Relies on Skinner v. American State Bank · Lanterman v. Dorgan · Hardy v. State Tax Commissioner

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1980-12-19

How this case has been cited

Cited by 6 later decisions — most recently June 2002

6 state decisions

30198019902000decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

VANDE WALLE, Justice,

¶1concurring specially.

¶2If we were reviewing these issues for the first time, I might well agree with Justice Paulson’s dissent in Lanterman v. Dorgan, 255 N.W.2d 891, 895 (N.D.1977). However, as the opinion by the Chief Justice notes, this court has previously reviewed these issues in Lantermanand Hardy v. State Tax Commissioner, 258 N.W.2d 249 (N.D.1977). Those opinions concluded that the North Dakota statutes require the Federal taxable income as the starting point for the preparation of the State income tax return and only those adjustments expressly provided by statute may be made to increase or decrease Federal taxable income on the State tax return.

¶3We were told at oral argument by counsel for the Tax Commissioner that Lanter-man and Hardywere incorrect decisions, that some legislators agreed those decisions were incorrect interpretations of the statute, and that it was the conclusion of the legislators and the tax department that no further legislation was necessary because the decisions were incorrect. These statements are not, of course, part of the record. However, such a conclusion is not a correct reflection of the law. The construction of a statute by the courts, supported by long acquiescence on the part of the Legislature, or by continued use of the same language, or failure to amend the statute, is evidence that such construction is in accordance with the legislative intent. See, e. g., Skinner v. American State Bank, 189 N.W.2d 665 (N.D.1971). Thus, if the interpretation placed upon statutes by this court is incorrect, the Legislature presumably would take action by the amendment of the statutes to correct that interpretation. Although the interpretation in Lantermanand Hardymay not be indicative of “long acquiescence on the part of the Legislature,” we were also informed at oral argument that no bills addressing these issues were introduced into the 46th Legislative Assembly which convened in 1979 — after the decisions in those cases had been announced for some time. If the argument of counsel for the Tax Commissioner that no legislative amendments were necessary is accepted, it appears that even if this case had not arisen for some period of years after Lantermanthere still would have been no legislative proposals made to address these issues.

¶4Because this court has previously determined these issues and because there was no legislative action to alter those decisions, I concur in the opinion written by the Chief Justice.

/300/nw2d/834 · .json · Public domain