inline">306 Ga. 364

FINAL COPY

               S19A0297. BAILEY v. THE STATE.


     BLACKWELL, Justice.

     Phillip Bailey appeals from the denial of his motion for leave to

pursue an out-of-time appeal. Pursuant to a plea agreement, Bailey

pleaded guilty in 2007 to the murder of Jess Sharp and an

aggravated assault upon Lamar Sharp, and Bailey was sentenced to

imprisonment for life for the murder and a concurrent term of

imprisonment for 20 years for the aggravated assault. He did not

bring a timely appeal from the judgment of conviction entered upon

his plea.

     More than eleven years later, Bailey filed a motion for leave to

pursue an out-of-time appeal. In his motion, Bailey alleged, among

other things, that he was denied the effective assistance of counsel

in connection with his plea and that his plea was involuntary. Bailey

did not allege, however, that he was denied the effective assistance

of counsel in connection with his failure to bring a timely appeal.
Nor did he allege that his failure to bring a timely appeal was

attributable to any other error of constitutional magnitude. The trial

court denied his motion without an evidentiary hearing.

     The trial court was right to deny the motion. As we have

explained,

     before being entitled to an out-of-time appeal, a defendant
     must allege and prove an excuse of constitutional
     magnitude for failing to file a timely direct appeal, which
     usually is done by showing that the delay was caused by
     his trial counsel’s ineffective assistance in providing
     advice about or acting upon an appeal.

Deloney v. State,

302 Ga. 142, 145

 (2) (

805 SE2d 881

) (2017).

Although Bailey alleged in his motion that he was denied the

effective assistance of counsel in other respects, he did not allege

that he was denied the effective assistance of counsel in connection

with his failure to bring a timely appeal. Accordingly, he is not

entitled to an out-of-time appeal. See Grace v. State,

295 Ga. 657, 658

 (2) (a) (

763 SE2d 461

) (2014) (motion for out-of-time appeal was

properly denied where defendant “did not allege that ineffective

assistance of counsel was the cause of his failure to file a timely
direct appeal from the judgment entered on his guilty plea”). See

also McMullen v. State,

292 Ga. 355, 356

 (2) (

737 SE2d 102

) (2013)

(same).

     Judgment affirmed. All the Justices concur.
       Decided May 20, 2019 – Reconsideration dismissed July 1,

                               2019.

     Murder. Cobb Superior Court, Before Judge Childs.

     Phillip Ray Bailey, pro se.

     D. Victor Reynolds, District Attorney, John R. Edwards,

Benjamin M. First, Assistant District Attorneys; Christopher M.

Carr, Attorney General, Patricia B. Attaway Burton, Deputy

Attorney General, Paula K. Smith, Senior Assistant Attorney

General, Katherine D. Emerson, Assistant Attorney General, for

appellee.

Citation profile

Relationships

How this case has been treated — in progress