Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist
← 308 NY 218 - Gaines v. Jacobsen

Gaines v. Jacobsen’s Empirical Analysis

1954

Citation profile

114
cited by 114 later decisions
21
states following
December 2005
most recently cited

19 federal appellate · 76 state decisions

How this case has been cited

Cited by 114 later decisions — most recently December 2005 · most notably 45 Cal. 2d 872 - Sefton v. Sefton (1955), Procter & Gamble Distributing Co. v. Lawrence American Field Warehousing Corp. (1965)

19 federal appellate · 76 state decisions — followed in 21 states

420195419601970198019902000decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

Relationships

Relies on American Surety Co. v. Conner · Sleicher v. Sleicher · Nelson v. Nelson · International Text Book Co. v. . Connelly · Johnson v. Johnson

Most-quoted passages

The sentences later courts lift from this opinion, ranked by how many decisions quote each — the parts of the opinion doing the work. These counts are smaller than the citation total above because most of the 114 citing decisions cite the case generally; a passage count includes only decisions quoting that exact language verbatim.

  1. ““Rather, the understanding must have been that, upon the wife’s remarriage, the husband could regard himself as free of the duty to support her. He could then assume new obligations — he could himself remarry, if he were of a mind to, but his means limited — without remaining forever subject to the possibility that his first wife’s remarriage would be annulled and the burden of supporting her shifted back to him. And the wife, too, must have understood that by remarrying she abandoned her rights to support under the agreement, for better or for worse, in favor of whatever support would be furnished her by her second mate.” 124 N.E.2d at 293-294 .”
    6 later decisions quote this exact passage
  2. ““Today, through the operation of section 1140-a, the wife can receive support from the husband of the annulled marriage, where ‘justice requires,’ and there is no more reason to revive the obligation of the first husband — a stranger to the annulment — than there would be if the remarriage were terminated by divorce. * * * “Not only does the practical justification for the Sleicher decision fall with the enactment of section 1140-a, but its doctrinal basis becomes extremely questionable as well. The fiction that annulment effaces a marriage ‘as if it had never been’ is sometimes given effect and sometimes ignored, as the ‘purposes of justice’ are deemed to require. * -» * “By writing section 1140-a into the law, the legislature has chosen, without regard to whether the marriage is void or voidable, to attach to annulled marriages sufficient validity and significance to support an award of alimony, in other words, to serve, the same as any valid marriage would, as the foundation of a continuing duty to support the wife after the marriage is terminated. See Johnson v. Johnson, 295 N.Y. 477 , 68 N.E.2d 499 . It has declared, in effect, that, for the purpose of sustaining a right to support after annulment, the annulled marriage is no longer to be deemed a nullity, ‘effaced as if it had never been.’ In so doing, the legislature has destroyed the very foundation of the Sleicher decision. * * * ””
    3 later decisions quote this exact passage
  3. ““At the time of the Sleicher decision, it was impossible for a wife to obtain alimony or other support upon annulment of a marriage; it followed inexorably, from the theory that an annulled marriage never existed, that such a'marriage created no subsequent duty of support. See Jones v. Brinsmade, 183 N.Y. 258 , 76 N.E. 22 , 3 L.R.A.,N.S., 192. To have held otherwise than the court did in Sleicher would, therefore, have deprived the wife in that case of any source of support whatsoever. However, since that time, the legislature has enacted section 1140-a of the Civil Practice Act, which provides that “ ‘When an action is brought to annul a marriage or to declare the nullity of a void marriage, the court may give such direction for support of the wife by the husband to justice requires’. “This new provision, respondent urges, by removing the primary and underlying motivation for the Sleicher decision, distinguishes that case from the one before us and justifies us in reaching a different conclusion. Appellant, on the other hand, contends that there is no basis for distinguishing Sleicher, and that it is dispositive of this appeal. “While resolution of the dispute may not be easy, it is our opinion that the new enactment, after the date of the Sleicher decision, alters the situation before us so materially that it calls for a different result in this case.””
    1 later decision quote this exact passage

How this case has been treated — in progress

Whether each later court followed, distinguished, criticized, or overruled this decision. The treatment classification (task #35) runs highest-cited cases first and lights up here as it reaches this one.