Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

31 Ill. 460

Fender v. Stiles

Illinois Supreme Court

Decided April 15, 1863

Illinois Supreme Court · decided 1863-04-15

<p>1. Pleading — averments in declaration on bond, of indemnity. A and B placed money which they had het npon a horse race, in the hands of C, as stake-holder. A dispute arose as to which was entitled to the money, A or B. But the stake-holder gave the whole of the money to B, upon his giving him a hond of indemnity against any suit or demand of A in that regard. A afterwards recovered from the stake-holder the money which ho had deposited with him. It was held, that in an action upon his hond of indemnity, C must aver either that the obligor had notice of the action by A against him,, or that A really had a good cause of action on.which he recovered, or might have recovered the money.</p> <p>2. But in this case, it appearing from the bond, which constituted a part of the declaration, that' A ought to have recovered the portion of the money which he deposited with the stake-holder, it was enough that the latter averred in his declaration on the bond, that such recovery was had.</p> <p>3. Judgment against those, of several defendomis, -who a/re served. Where two only, of three defendants in an action of debt, are served with process, it is proper to take judgment against the two upon whom service was had.</p>

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1863-04-15

How this case has been cited

Cited by 4 later decisions — most recently February 1947

4 state decisions

10186318701880189019001910192019301940decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Mr. Chief Justice OatoN,

¶1delivered the opinion of the Court.

¶2The only question in this case, of the least importance, is as to the sufficiency of‘the declaration. That must show, either that the obligors had notice of the action against the obligee, and an opportunity to defend it, or else, that Atkins really had a good cause of action on which he recovered, or might have recovered, against the obligee. Such we regard the rights of the obligors in a bond of indemnity. There is no averment that the obligors had any opportunity of defending any action or proceeding .against the obligee; but the bond shows upon its face, that Atkins had a cause of action against the plaintiff, upon which he had a right to recover, and that bond is set out in, and constitutes a part of, the declaration. It shows that Atkins had deposited money with Stiles, as stakes upon a horse-race. And we know, as a matter of law, that Atkins had a right to recover from Stiles the money thus deposited, no matter what the event of the race was. The case is the same as if the bond had recited, that Stiles had so mucb money in his hands, which Fender wanted him to pay over to hirn, to indemnify him for doing which, the bond was given. ' Oould any other averment or statement be required, in order to show that Atkins had rightfully recovered against Stiles ? The declaration is sufficient.

¶3Three parties were sued, and two only were served, and judgment was rendered only against them; and this is complained of as error. This was in pursuance of the express and literal provisions of the statute,* and was, of course, right.

¶4There is some complaint about the amount of damages. This amount' was expressly agreed upon by the parties, as appears from the record.,

¶5The judgment is affirmed. Judgment affirmed.

¶6 Rev. Stat. 1845, 413, see. 6.

/31/ill/460 · .json · Public domain