Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

31 Ill. App. 30

Lutterell v. Caldwell

Appellate Court of Illinois

Decided February 21, 1889

Appellate Court of Illinois · decided 1889-02-21

<p>Í Instructions—Division' Fence—Trespass.</p> <p>It is error to give an instruction which has no basis in the evidence.</p>

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently March 1926

1 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1889-02-21

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Per Curiam.

¶1This suit grew out of a contention between the parties hereto as to the true location of the line dividing their farms, and consequently whether Lutterell was a trespasser in plowing up a hedge claimed by one to be on such line, and by Lutterell as being entirely on his land.

¶2The court gave the following instruction:

“ That if they believe, from the evidence, that the old fence, moved by the plaintiffs to make room for the setting of the hedge in question, was placed there by the defendant Lutterell as a temporary fence, to remain only until Mr. or Mrs. Caldwell should set a hedge upon the line between their lan.Is, and that such fence was never recognized or admitted by the plaintiffs or those under whom they claim title to be the true line, then plaintiffs were not estopped thereby to place tlicir hedge upon the true line between said lands, although the true line might differ from the line of the old fence.”

¶3We fail to find any evidence in the record upon which this instruction could be based. It was misleading, for it tended to make the jury suppose that the court was referring to the original fence as built by the ancestor of appellant, and there was no evidence to show that it was built for a temporary purpose.

¶4This was an important question in the case, and we think this instruction tended to mislead-the jury upon it, and therefor- there should be a new trial.

¶5The judgment of the Circuit Court will be reversed and the cause remanded.

¶6Reversed and remanded.

/31/illapp/30 · .json · Public domain