Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

31 Misc. 820

Marggraf v. McLean

City of New York Municipal Court · decided 1900-05-15

<p>Appeal from a judgment in favor of plaintiff.</p>

Decided 1900-05-15

Eitzsimocts, Ck. J.

¶1The plaintiff was bound to prove that the testator engaged him to perform the services sued for, or that they were performed with his knowledge or consent. 6 App. Div. 535. No attempt was made to offer such testimony. The defendant’s testator was, so far as the evidence in this case shows, apparently entirely ignorant of the fact that the said services were rendered, or material furnished. Therefore, plaintiff has. no legal right to ask compensation therefor. The verdict is,, therefore, against the law and the evidence and must be reversed.

¶2It is so directed and a new trial is ordered, with costs to appellant,

¶3Sohtjohmah, J., concurs.

¶4Judgment reversed, and new trial ordered, with costs to appellant.

/31/misc/820 · .json · Public domain