¶1(specially concurring). I concur in the result of the above opinion, but do not wish to express an opinion on all of the questions involved and discussed. I have no doubt that as a general proposition “a defendant in.an attachment case cannot set up title in a stranger to defeat the attachment levy as on his property.” I am in doubt, however, whether such a rule applies where the defendant holds such property, or claims to hold such property, as a trustee for another. The reason I concur in the opinion is that the question of the ownership is one of the main issues presented by the complaint, and I do not believe that such issue should be allowed to be tried on affidavits and on a motion to quash the attachment.
31 ND 651
Thornley v. Lawbaugh
Decided September 22, 1913
North Dakota Supreme Court · decided 1913-09-22
Appeal by plaintiff from an order of the district court of McLean county, Winchester, J., quashing an attachment and dismissing the action. The alleged trust, as between the defendant and the grantors in the deed conveying the property .in question to him, is void. Rev. Codes 1905., §§ 4821, 4835, Comp. Laws 1913, §§ 5364, 5378; Enderlin Invest. Co. v. Nordhagen, 18 N. D. 517, 123 N. W. 390.
Reversed and remanded · Decided 1913-09-22