Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

313 Ga. 458

870 S.E.2d 404

Monroe v. State

Supreme Court of Georgia

Decided March 8, 2022

Supreme Court of Georgia · decided 2022-03-08

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently November 2024

1 state decisions

Relies on Daubert v. Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals, Inc. · Mason v. Home Depot U.S.A., Inc. · Mitchell v. State

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 2022-03-08

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1 SUPREME COURT OF GEORGIA Case No. S22I0114 & S22A0324

¶2 March 8, 2022

¶3 The Honorable Supreme Court met pursuant to adjournment.

¶4The following order was passed:

¶5 DAVID CHAVELL MONROE v. THE STATE.

¶6 Upon review of the full record and the briefs of the parties, this Court has determined that the application for interlocutory appeal in this case was improvidently granted. Accordingly, the order granting the application is vacated, the application is denied, and the appeal is dismissed.

¶7 All the Justices concur.

¶8 SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF GEORGIA Clerk’s Office, Atlanta

¶9 I certify that the above is a true extract from the minutes of the Supreme Court of Georgia. Witness my signature and the seal of said court hereto affixed the day and year last above written.

¶10 , Clerk S22A0324. MONROE v. THE STATE.

¶11 PETERSON, Justice, concurring.

¶12 We granted Monroe’s application for interlocutory appeal to

¶13decide the significant question of whether a competency trial is a

¶14civil proceeding subject to the standard for admission of expert

¶15testimony set forth in OCGA § 24-7-702 (“Rule 702”), which

¶16incorporates into Georgia law for civil cases the holding of Daubert

¶17v. Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals, Inc., 509 U.S. 579 (113 SCt 2786,

¶18125 LE2d 469) (1993). See Rule 702 (a), (b), (f). This remains an

¶19important issue. Unfortunately, we have discovered a defect in this

¶20case that prevents us from reaching its merits here.

¶21 “An appellant’s failure to attack alternative bases for a

¶22judgment results in the affirmance of that judgment.” Brown v.

¶23Fokes Props. 2002, Inc., 283 Ga. 231, 233 (2) (657 SE2d 820) (2008).

¶24Here, the trial court resolved Monroe’s claim that the Daubert

¶25standard should apply on both timeliness and substantive grounds.

¶26At trial, it ruled that Monroe was not entitled to seek a hearing to

¶27litigate the expert testimony under Rule 702 because he did not

¶28 2 request one before trial as required by the trial court’s interpretation

¶29of the Rule. In its order denying Monroe’s motion for new trial, the

¶30trial court held that the Daubert standard does not apply to

¶31competency trials because such proceedings are “quasi-criminal” in

¶32nature. But the court also noted its earlier timeliness ruling and left

¶33untouched its prior reasoning, even though it also provided an

¶34alternative ground for its decision.

¶35 Because Monroe has not challenged the timeliness rationale in

¶36his appeal, he has failed to attack an alternative basis for the

¶37judgment below. As such, this case does not properly present the

¶38merits of either issue, and we correctly dismiss it today as

¶39improvidently granted. See, e.g., Mendez v. Moats, 310 Ga. 114, 114-

¶4015 (852 SE2d 816) (2020) (Nahmias, P.J., concurring) (agreeing with

¶41vacation of writ of certiorari as improvidently granted, despite

¶42important questions presented, due to procedural defects that

¶43prevented resolving them).

¶44 This dismissal should not be understood as casting any doubt

¶45on the importance of the Daubert-related question. Indeed, although

¶46 3 not at issue in this case and despite this Court’s holding to the

¶47contrary on at least one potential constitutional ground, serious

¶48questions exist as to whether the United States and Georgia

¶49Constitutions permit the admission of expert testimony in criminal

¶50cases that is deemed insufficiently reliable in civil cases. See, e.g.,

¶51Woods v. State, 310 Ga. 358, 359 (850 SE2d 735) (2020) (Nahmias,

¶52P.J., concurring, joined by Blackwell and Peterson, JJ) (expressing

¶53inclination in an appropriate case “to grant a petition for certiorari

¶54asking this Court to reconsider its equal protection holding in Mason

¶55v. Home Depot U.S.A., Inc., 283 Ga. 271, 273-275 (658 SE2d 603)

¶56(2008), as summarily extended to claims by criminal defendants in

¶57Mitchell v. State, 301 Ga. 563, 571-572 (802 SE2d 217) (2017)”).

¶58 I am authorized to state that Chief Justice Nahmias and

¶59Presiding Justice Boggs join in this concurrence.

¶60 4

/313/ga/458 · .json · Public domain