Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

32 How. Pr. 400

Russell v. Russell

New York Supreme Court

Decided December 15, 1859

New York Supreme Court · decided 1859-12-15

This is a certiorari from the judgment of a justice of the peace in summary proceedings. The defendant in'error presented to the justice an affidavit, upon which he issued his summons.

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently June 1927

1 state decisions

Relies on Bradish v. Schenck · Oakley v. Schoonmaker · Evertson v. Sutton

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1859-12-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

By the court, Hogeboom, J.

¶1The affidavit made by the defendant in error; was clearly insufficient to give the justice jurisdiction. The facts stated therein, simply show “ a cropping or cultivating of land on shares,” and by numerous authorities, and a series of well adjudicated decisions, the parties in such eases are tenants in common. (15 Barb. S. C. R. 595, 833 ; 16 How. Pr. R. 454 ; 3 Barb. S. C. R. 397; 15 Wend. 228; 8 Johns. 151; 3 Id. 121; 2 Id. 421; 8 Cowen, 220; 1 Wend. 385; 4 Kent’s Com. 95; Taylor’s Land. & Ten. 720; 26 Eng. Law & Eq. R. 139 ; 1 Hill, 234 ; 7 N. H. R. 306-8 ; Cro. Eliz. 143.)

¶2And it is equally well settled that in such cases no realtion of landlord and tenant exists. (See authorities before cited.) The affidavit must show the conventional relation of landlord and tenant, and that by an agreement, before the applicant is entitled to this remedy. (1 Seld. R. 383.; 5 Wend. 281; 3 Barb. S. C. R. 397; 4 Denio, 71; 24 Barb. S. C. R. 438; 1 Hill, 314; Lal. Sup. to Hill & Denio, 236.) And the affidavit must show the tenant’s relation to the landlord to be that of landlord and tenant by conventional agreement, and not by mere operation of law.

¶3The affidavit showing no such relation of landlord and tenant, the justice clearly erred in issuing his summons, as well in not discharging the proceedings on motion of the plaintiffs in error, for the reasons I have given.

¶4The judgment and proceedings before the justice should be reversed.

/32/howpr/400 · .json · Public domain