Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

32 Mass. 212

Payson v. Whitcomb

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · decided 1834-03-15

<p>In an action against the maker of a promissory note given in consideration of the assignment of a mortgage, which mortgage was duly recorded, the defendant cannot give in evidence the fact that the mortgage was fraudulent and therefore void aa against creditors and subsequent purchasers, since if he was a bond fide assignee without notice of die fraud, his title under the assignment is valid, and if he knew of the fraud, then he must be considered as having waived any objection on account of the defect in the assignor’s title.</p> <p>A promissory note given on condition that the payee would assign Co the maker a mortgage of land, is admissible in evidence under a count for money had and received, the condition having been performed.</p> <p>Where all the counts in a declaration are for the same cause of action, but some of them are defective, and a general verdict is rendered for the plaintiff, the verdict may be applied to one of the good counts.</p> <p>In an action on a promissory note payable at a time and place certain, it is not necessary for the plaintiff to aver and prove a presentment at such time and place; and it is incumbent on the defendant to show, by way of defence, that he was ready to pay at such time and place.</p>

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently August 1955

1 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1834-03-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Wilde J.

¶1delivered the opinion of the Court. The defendant moves for a new trial, and also in arrest of judgment; but it does not appear to us that there is any sufficient ground ,on which either of these motions can be sustained. The instructions to the jury were clearly correct.

¶2In support of the motion in arrest it is objected, that the special counts are insufficient, and that the evidence does not support the count for money had and received. We are, however, of opinion, that the count for money had and received is well sustained by the evidence, and that the plaintiff is entitled to judgment on that count. As all the counts are for the same demand, the verdict, though general, may be applied to the good count.

¶3The objection, that no money has teen received by the *216defendant, and therefore an action for money had and received will not lie, cannot be maintained. It is sufficient that the defendant has received money’s worth, and that at tne time the action was commenced, he was indebted to the plaintiff in the sum claimed, which was then due and payable in money. For there can be no doubt, as Chief Justice Sewall remarks, in the case of Young v. Adams, 6 Mass. R. 189, that for a sum of money, which has become due upon a promissory note or bill, an action against the promisor, for money received to the use of the promisee in the note or bill, may be maintained. So an indorsee of a promissory note payable to order, or the bearer of a note payable to bearer, may maintain an action in the same form against the maker. Grant v. Vaughan, 3 Burr. 1516 ; Dimsdale v. Lanchester, 4 Esp. R. 201. It is immaterial what is the consideration of the note, if it is a valid security for a debt due payable in money. This is now a familiar principle. The cases of Dutch v. Warren, 2 Burr. 1011, Randall v. Rich, 11 Mass. R. 494, and Floyd v. Day, 3 Mass. R. 403, establish the same general principle.

¶4But it has been argued, that as the note was payable at a place certain, it was necessary for the plaintiff to prove a demand of payment at that place. Whatever may be considered the law in England on this point, it has been settled in this Commonwealth, that no such demand is necessary. The question was fully discussed and considered in Carley v. Vance, 17 Mass. R. 389. It was incumbent on the defendant to show, by way of defence, that he was ready to pay at the time and place specified in the note.

¶5 Judgment on the verdict on the count for money had and re eeived

/32/mass/212 · .json · Public domain