Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

32 Misc. 638

Jones v. Bohm

City of New York Municipal Court

Decided October 15, 1900

City of New York Municipal Court · decided 1900-10-15

<p>Demurrer — Will not lie to matter pleaded in mitigation of damages — Code C. P., § 494.</p> <p>A demurrer will not lie to matter pleaded in an answer in mitigation of damages, as, under the Code of Civil Procedure, § 494, only matter pleaded by way of counterclaim or defense is demurrable.</p>

Decided 1900-10-15

Conlan, J.

¶1The record brings up for review two appeals: One, from an interlocutory judgment sustaining a demurrer to matter pleaded in the answer in mitigation of damages only, and the other, from an order denying the defendant’s motion to compel the plaintiff to accept a proposed amended answer.

¶2As to the first appeal, we are of the opinion that the demurrer should have been overruled. The matter demurred to was pleaded in mitigation of damages and was, therefore, not the subject of a demurrer. Under section 494 of the Code of Civil Procedure only matter pleaded by way of counterclaim or defense, in an answer, can be demurred to. The order sustaining the demurrer will be overruled and the interlocutory judgment vacated. Costs of the appeal to appellant.

¶3As to the second appeal, we agree with the order made. The defendant’s time to serve his proposed amended answer had clearly expired. The order should be affirmed, with costs to the respondent.

¶4Hascall, J., concurs.

¶5Order affirmed, with costs.

/32/misc/638 · .json · Public domain