Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

33 Barb. 320

Barhyte v. Hughes

New York Supreme Court

Decided February 4, 1861

New York Supreme Court · decided 1861-02-04

The action was for an assault and battery. The complaint was the ordinary complaint in such cases.

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1861-02-04

How this case has been cited

Cited by 11 later decisions — most recently February 1921

11 state decisions

401861187018801890190019101920decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1*321By the Court,

Clerke, J.

¶2This is an action for an assault and battery. The answer denies each and every allegation in the complaint, and sets up as a separate defense, “that the plaintiff just before the time when the defendant is alleged in said complaint to have assaulted the plaintiff, made an unprovoked and violent assault upon the defendant by beating, striking and kicking him, without cause or provocation.”

¶3Supposing this matter to be properly alleged as a counterclaim, the question arising in this case is, whether a counterclaim is allowable in an action of tort, for a cause arising out of the occurrence set forth in the complaint.

¶4Before the. adoption of the code, no claim could be affirmatively set up in opposition to that of the plaintiff but what was technically called 1st, a set-off, and 2d, a recoupment. Neither would have been allowed in an action of tort.

¶5The only ground upon which it can be pretended that the code has extended this right to actions of tort is, that the first subdivision of section 150, allows a cause of action arising out of the contract or transaction set forth in the complaint to be the subject of a counter-claim. But the introduction of the word' transaction is scarcely sufficient to warrant us in determining that so radical a change was contemplated by the legislature, as that contended for by the defendant’s counsel. The word “transaction” undoubtedly is one of a very general nature, and of more extensive signification than “ contract,” but it was frequently employed by the courts in juxta-position with the latter term in referring to or commenting upon the right to recoup, and never of course deemed in relation to that subject to signify tortious acts. Even in popular language no one would speak of an assault or a slander, or false imprisonment, or a cheat, as a transaction. This word is used in application to some commercial or business negotiation, not to a wrong caused by an act of violence or fraud. The transactions meant were those, which, although not precisely contracts yet, being dealings *322or business matters of some kind, would entitle a party to , a remedy in an action ex contractu, and would entitle a defendant in such an action to recou/p any damages for a cause arising out of such dealings or matters. If the legislature intended to extend -this right to actions of tort, it would have expressly declared its intention ; but instead of this' it has employed no language in relation to a counter-claim which was not before employed in relation to a recoupment. The exceptions are all alike untenable. -

[New York General Term,February 4, 1861.

¶6Clerke, Sutherland and Allen, Justices.]

¶7The judgment should be affirmed with costs.

/33/barb/320 · .json · Public domain