Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

33 Ga. 49

McCurdy v. Terry

Supreme Court of Georgia

Decided August 15, 1861

Supreme Court of Georgia · decided 1861-08-15

<p>1. A'party, plaintiff or defendant, may begin at either end of his testimony, upon the assurance of counsel, that he expects to supply all . the links in the testimony necessary to make out his case.</p> <p>&. When a case is in the last resort, testimony taken by interrogatories and commissions, can only be objected to on the ground of irrelevancy.</p> <p>3. In a suit brought to recover notes given for a negro slave, a receipt given by the vendor to the vendee, for the purchase price of the slave, is admissable in evidence, although the receipt contains no covenant of warranty.</p> <p>4. The refusal of the Court to suspend the trial and continue a case, to enable a party who is surprised by the testimony of a witness, to obtain evidence to impeach him, is not a sufficient ground for a new trial.</p> <p>5. A witness who is interested in the event of the suit, is incompetent to testify in behalf of the party with whom his interest lies.</p> <p>6. An attorney at law, without special authority, is not competent to release a witness for his client.</p> <p>7. It is not error for the Court to refuse to suspend the trial, and continue a case, in order to enable an attorney to obtain from his absent client, a release to a witness. This is especially so, where the client was apprised of the necessity of the release.</p> <p>8. The refusal to charge what is not law, is no ground for a new trial.</p> <p>O. Newly discovered evidence which is merely cumulative, and which ought not to change the verdict if admitted, is no ground for a new trial.</p>

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1861-08-15

How this case has been cited

Cited by 5 later decisions — most recently February 1965

5 state decisions

2018611870188018901900191019201930194019501960decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

By the, Court —

¶1Lumpkin, J., delivering the opinion.

¶2Samuel Rawlins sold to William Terry, a negro man named Harry, for which he gave him sixteen fifty dollar •notes. Rawlins transferred the notes to David R. McCurdy," who brought this action upon them. The defendant pleaded a failure of consideration, and knowledge of the fact by the plaintiff before he became the holder of the notes. In other words, that he was not a bona fide holder. The plaintiff read *55the notes to the jury on the trial, and closed his case. The defendant proposed offering evidence to show that the consideration of the notes sued on had failed, which was objected to, until notice was brought home to the plaintiff. The objection was overruled by the Court, and we think, properly. It has been again and again ruled by this and all Courts, that a party, plaintiff or defendant, may begin at either end of his testimony, upon the assurance of counsel, that he expected to supply all the links in the testimony necessary to make out his case.

¶3The defendant offered to read the deposition of Eobert Watson, to certain interrogatives, which was objected to on the ground that the interrogatories had been once answered, and the answers suppressed by order of the Court, and that they had been, after that, taken from the Clerk’s office and re-executed before'different commissioners, without leave of the Court, or notice to the other party. What of that ? The ease was submitted to the jury, and the statute is imperative that, that being the case, the interrogatories could only be objected to on the ground of irrelevancy. We must presume that they were in the office in time to make the objection.

¶4We cannot see the point of the objection to the reading of the receipt for eight hundred dollars paid by Terry to Eawlins, for the negro. To proof of the request by Eawlins, to Cockerell, to bring old man Terry over to attend a “big hard-shell meeting” which never eame off, plaintiff objected, and we think he was right in trying to exclude this testimony, as it was the commencement of this nefarious fraud. But the Court, for that reason, was equally right in overruling the objection. Plaintiff being surprised by the testimony of Stephen McGinness, moved to continue the case, to prove the general bad character of the witness, which probably he could have done, the name being suggestive. But this would have constituted no ground for a new trial, after verdict, and we think it was not sufficient to continue the case. Samuel Eawlins was properly excluded as a witness. If the notes were lost by McCurdy, on account of the failure of consideration, Eawlins was clearly liable to make good *56the loss. Neither was it competent for the attorney to release him. It does not come within the scope of his employment. Neither could the case be continued to get McCurdy there* for that purpose. Eor counsel had talked the matter over with his client, and he gave him verbal authority to execute a release. He was apprised of theliecessity of it.

¶5As to the charge requested of the Court, it was not war-rented by the evidence. Besides'it was not a matter of law. The jury might, had they seen fit, have believed the testimony of the physician, in opposition to that of the two witnesses to the transaction, without violating any principle or rule of law.

¶6As to the newly- discovered evidence, in addition to the objection, that it was cumulative merely, the Court is satisfied, that it could not change the verdict, and that it ought not to have that effect. The testimony unmistakably establishes, that not only a most wicked fraud was practiced by Rawlins on Terry, but that he still is the owner of Terry’s notes, the transfer to McCurdy being colorable only.

¶7Let the judgment be affirmed.

/33/ga/49 · .json · Public domain