Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

332 F.2d 397

Docket No. 6301

Merritt v. United States

First Circuit Court of Appeals

Decided June 1, 1964.

First Circuit Court of Appeals · decided 1964-06-01

2 counsel of record

Key passage — most relied on by later courts

“(b) The remedy against the United States provided by sections 1346(b) and 2672 of this title for injury or loss of property or personal injury or death, resulting from the operation by any employee of the Government of any motor vehicle while acting within the scope of his office or employment, shall hereafter be exclusive of any other civil action or proceeding by reason of the same subject matter against the employee or his estate whose act or omission gave rise to the claim.”

quoted by 2 later decisions, including Borrego v. United States, Provost v. Smith

““It is settled that the phrase 'acting in line of duty,’ while having a military sound, and, apparently, a different meaning in connection with benefit claims of military personnel against the government, with respect to the Tort Claims Act merely invokes the state law of respondeat superior. Williams v. United States, 1955, 350 U.S. 857 , 76 S.Ct. 100 , 100 L.Ed. 761 ; United States v. Taylor, 6 Cir., 1956, 236 F.2d 649 , 74 A.L.R.2d 860 , cert. dismissed, 355 U.S. 801 , 78 S.Ct. 6 , 2 L.Ed.2d 19 ; United States v. Hainline, 10 Cir., 1963, 315 F.2d 153 , cert. den. 375 U.S. 895 , 84 S.Ct. 172 , 11 L.Ed. 2d 124 .””

quoted by 1 later decision, including McCall v. United States

Applies 28 U.S.C. § 1346 (Federal Tort Claims Act) · 28 U.S.C. § 2671

Relies on Williams v. United States · United States Gypsum Co. v. Glander · Ross v. United States

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1964-06-01

How this case has been cited

Cited by 33 later decisions — most recently January 1995 · most notably Joseph v. Office of the Consulate General of Nigeria (1987), Attallah v. United States (1992)

20 federal appellate · 7 district ·

1201964197019801990decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1*398Andrew L. Benson, Winthrop, Mass., for appellants.

¶2Morton Hollander, Atty., Dept, of Justice, with whom John W. Douglas, Asst. Atty. Gen., W. Arthur Garrity, Jr., U. S. Atty., and Harvey L. Zuckman, Atty., Dept. of Justice, were on brief, for appellee.

¶3Before WOODBURY, Chief Judge, and HARTIGAN and ALDRICH, Circuit Judges.

¶4ALDRICH, Circuit Judge.

¶5This is an action under the Federal Tort Claims Act.1 The plaintiffs, hereinafter referred to in the singular, leased a dwelling in Winthrop, Massachusetts to the government for use as off-post family housing for military personnel and their dependents. A sergeant, quartered therein, after finishing his duties for the day, negligently set fire to the house by smoking in bed. Title 28 U.S.C. § 1346 (b) provides for government tort liability for the acts of an employee “while acting within the scope of his office or employment ….” This, as to a member of the military, is defined to mean “acting in line of duty.” 28 U.S.C. § 2671. The district court,- finding the facts as above, dismissed the action, and plaintiff appeals.

¶6It is settled that the phrase “acting in line of duty,” while having a military sound, and, apparently, a different meaning in connection with benefit claims of military personnel against the government, with respect to the Tort Claims Act merely invokes the state law of respondeat superior. Williams v. United States, 1955, 350 U.S. 857, 76 S.Ct. 100, 100 L.Ed. 761; United States v. Taylor, 6 Cir., 1956, 236 F.2d 649, 74 A.L.R.2d 860, cert. dismissed, 355 U.S. 801, 78 S.Ct. 6, 2 L.Ed.2d 19; United States v. Hainline, 10 Cir., 1963, 315 F.2d 153, cert. den. 375 U.S. 895, 84 S.Ct. 172, 11 L.Ed.2d 124. We find nothing in the Massachusetts cases suggesting that an employee smoking in bed during his off *399hours is in the course of his employment. Plaintiff concedes that there would be no government liability for the sergeant’s negligence if he had been smoking, in, say, a public bar, but contends that the fact that the government supplied him with a residence meant that anything he was doing in the residence was in the scope of his employment. We would need persuasive authority to show that this was the Massachusetts law. Cf. Harrington v. Border City Mfg. Co., 1921, 240 Mass. 170, 132 N.E. 721, 18 A.L.R. 610; see also, Khoury v. Edison Elec. Illuminating Co., 1928, 265 Mass. 236, 164 N.E. 77, 60 A.L.R. 1159; Conversions & Surveys, Inc. v. Roach, 1 Cir., 1953, 204 F.2d 499.

¶7Alternatively, the plaintiff claims that the government is liable on a theory of tort in the nature of waste. It is clear under Massachusetts law that a tenant for years may be held answerable for waste for damage to the leasehold by fire attributable to his voluntary or negligent acts, or to those of his servants in the course of their employment. See Cawley v. Northern Waste Co., 1921, 239 Mass. 540, 132 N.E. 365; Mass.Gen. Laws c. 242, §§ 1, 2. For reasons already stated this does not advance the plaintiff. He urges, however, citing Fay v. Brewer, 1825, 3 Pick., Mass., 203, that the remedy is broader; that a tenant for years would be liable in tort to the reversioner for permissive waste on account of acts committed by a stranger, and for which the tenant is in no way at fault. It has been forcefully argued that Fay v. Brewer no longer represents the law of the Commonwealth. E. g., 5 American Law of Property § 20.13 (Casner ed. 1952); 1 Walsh, Commentary on Law of Real Property §§ 9, 46, 50 (1947); 1 Tiffany, Landlord & Tenant § 110 (1910). See also, 5 Powell, Real Property § 640 (Boyer ed. 1962).2 But even if it should still be the law of Massaehusetts we do not construe the Tort Claims Act, which provides for a waiver of immunity only for loss “caused by the negligent or wrongful act or omission of any employee … while acting within the scope of his office or employment,” 28 U.S.C. § 1346(b), as embracing liability in the absence of fault attributable on ordinary agency principles. See, e. g., United States v. Campbell, 5 Cir., 1949, 172 F.2d 500, cert. den. 337 U.S. 957, 69 S.Ct. 1532, 93 L.Ed. 1757; United States v. Eleazer, 4 Cir., 1949, 177 F.2d 914, cert. den. 339 U.S. 903, 70 S.Ct. 517, 94 L.Ed. 1333; United States v. Taylor, supra Whether plaintiff has a con-factual claim under the lease is not before us‘

¶8Judgment will be entered affirming the judgment of the District Court,

/332/f2d/397 · .json · Public domain