Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

34 La. 528

Friedlander v. Schmalinski

Supreme Court of Louisiana

Decided April 15, 1882

Supreme Court of Louisiana · decided 1882-04-15

Barbin, J. i. To bind a married woman, the creditor must prove either that the’ debt enured to her separate benefit, or that she was a public merchant, and the obligation was connected with her business as such. 15 A. 352 5 13 A. 540. % There is no proof that the obligation sued on had any connection with her business as merchant, or that it enured to her separate benefit. 3.

Relies on Neiman v. Delaware & Hudson Canal Co.

Decided 1882-04-15

¶1The opinion of the Court was delivered by

Fenner, J.

¶2This is a suit against a married woman ou the following obligation:

New Orleans, December 14, 1877.
Should certain securities (named below) not realize $3,400 net cash to Mr. S. Friedlander, during the year 1878,1 promise to pay ou demand, during January, 1879, to Mr. S. Friedlander, whatever amount less than $3,400 net cash said named securities shall have realized to Mr. S. Friedlander. Say, mortgage note Agricultural Fair Association, March 23, ’76, $915, with 8 per cent, interest, and 20 Rapides warrants, each for $100, with 5 per cent, from 14th July, 1874.
(Signed)' E. Schmalinski.
S.Schmalinski.

¶3The plaintiff alleges that the defendant was carrying on business aw a public merchant, as a member of a commercial firm of Schmalinski &. Bloom, and that this obligation is for an indebtedness growing out of her said business.

¶4In the absence of any brief of counsel for appellee, we have scrutinized the record very closely, in seach of evidence to establish that the obligation was given by Mrs. Schmalinski in her capacity of public merchant, of that it was connected with, or grew out of, tho business .of Schmalinski &■ Bloom.

¶5We find no such evidence.

¶6*529This proof was clearly essential in order to maintain the claim against her on that ground. Bowles vs. Turner, 15 A. 352.

¶7Proof is equally lacking that she was separate in property, or that, the debt enured to her separate benefit.

¶8In absence of such evidence, we can discover no ground on which this action against a married woman be sustained. Graham vs. Egan, 13 A. 546; Erwin vs. McCaleb, 5 A. 173; 19 A. 206; 24 A. 96.

¶9It is, therefore, ordered, adjudged and decreed, that the judgment appealed from be avoided and reversed, and that plaintiff’s demand he dismissed, as in case of non-suit.

/34/la/528 · .json · Public domain