Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

34 La. 588

Katz v. Sorsby

Supreme Court of Louisiana

Decided April 15, 1882

Supreme Court of Louisiana · decided 1882-04-15

<p>To entitle a party to appeal from an interlooutory judgment, the injury need not be irreparable 5 it is sufficient tliat it may become so by a final judgment.</p> <p>In garnishment proceedings in execution of a judgment obtained in an attachment suit, tho judgment debtor is not a necessary party to an appeal from a judgment hetw con creditor and garnishee.</p> <p>When an* insurance oompany made garnisheo, answering interrogatories, declares that it issued to the judgment debtor, a policy on a stock of goods for a stated amount; that said stock was burnt out, but tbe loss had not been adjusted, tlxe judgment creditor cannot on tho faoe of the answer, obtain a valid judgment ordering tbe company to adj ust the loss within a given delay, or else pay his judgment.</p> <p>Tho judgment oreditor has no greater rights than the assured, aud cannot exercise them without previously fulfilling all required conditions precedent.</p>

Relies on Pendleton v. Inhabitants of Northport

Decided 1882-04-15

¶1On the Merits.

Bermudez, C. J.

¶2The question to be decided in this case relates to the liability of a garnishee, answering interrogatories, under an attachment process.

¶3The plaintiffs seek to hold the London, Liverpool & Globe Insurance Company responsible for the judgment rendered against the defendant, on the face of the answer made by it,- and which is to the effect, that: “ the defendant was insured in said Company for $5,000, on stock of goods; that he was burnt out, but as loss has not been adjusted, Respondent is unable to say what will be found due him. Defendants’ interest in aforesaid policy was seized,” etc.

¶4The rule taken was filed more than two months after the answers of the garnishee had been part of record in the attachment proceedings.

¶5It does not appear that any issue was joined on the rule, or that any evidence was introduced on the trial. There was judgment ordering the garnishee to liquidate the amount of the loss and deposit the same with the sheriff, within ten days, or in default, that it be condemned to pay the amount of plaintiffs’ judgment.

¶6From this judgment the garnishee appealed.

¶7It is clear that by its answer, the garnishee did not admit owing the defendant any specific sum of money. Had it done so, and had the plaintiffs been satisfied with the answer, their remedy would have simply been to obtain an order directing the payment of the money into the hands of the sheriff, who would have receipted therefor.

¶8The garnishee merely admitted that the defendant might have a claim against it, but that it had not been adjusted, as yet.

¶9As the attaching plaintiff can acquire no other or greater rights against the garnishee than the defendant, it follows that, though the garnishee be indebted to the defendant, yet if there be anything to be *592done, as a condition precedent, to his recovering his debt in an action against the garnishee, the plaintiff cannot obtain judgment, against the garnishee without performing the condition. It is not enough to charge the garnishee that he owes something to the defendant. The amount owing must be shown. Drake on Attachments, Sec. 553. '

¶10The record does not establish that the judgment creditor lias proved any of the facts which it would have been incumbent on the insured to have alleged and proved, previous to a recovery. There is not even an allegation of liability, for any. specific amount, on the part of the Company to the insured. Even if the answer of the garnishee, apparently adopted by the rule, could be considered as part of it, the amount of the loss sustained, and therefore due to the insured, not having been admitted by the Company, no order to liquidate, no money judgment could have been rendered against it, as was done. It may still well be, that in a proper proceeding to hold it liable under the policy, the Company may have some valid, exonerating defense to set up, which it was not hound to interpose on the rule in this ease.

¶11In the absence of any issue joined and of evidence introduced, the defense must he considered as having been one of no cause of action. This view of the case dispenses us from determining whether or not the rule was seasonably taken. Act 27, E. S. 1877; 5 R. 447; 16 A. 253; 31 A. 548.

¶12Whatever may be the rights of the judgment creditors under the garnishment proceeding, the same remain unimpaired, in the condition in which they stood at the date of the seizure.

¶13It is, therefore, ordered and decreed, that the judgment appealed from he reversed, and that the rule therein rendered be dismissed, with costs, in both Courts.

/34/la/588 · .json · Public domain